Article
How companies implement resilience in their supply chains
By Ralf W. Seifert and Florian Lücker
June 2014
PRINTABLE PDF – Less than 1MB
Supply chain resilience has drawn the attention of companies and policy makers. Numerous studies and analyses have appeared in recent times that underline the importance of this topic in a globalized world. But what about the implementation of supply chain resilience? Do companies have the capabilities to address resilience? And where do they still need to improve to make sure that they are prepared for the next disaster?
To address these questions we conducted a survey with 85 multinational companies across industries and conducted a series of 20 structured interviews. Our five-pillar analysis provides detailed insights on the strengths and weaknesses of companies with respect to their risk management strategies. The first pillar (Vulnerability) assesses the risk exposure of a company, followed by the risk identification pillar (Management Culture) and the actual mitigation pillars (Procurement, Operations, and Demand & Visibility).
Pillar 1 – Vulnerability
When analyzing the vulnerability of a supply chain, a key challenge is to identify its bottleneck as Joos Verstraete, Director of Supply Chain External Operations EMEA at a major pharma company, points out:
“A disruption like a natural disaster in certain regions where suppliers control the worldwide supply of certain components/products would affect all players in the industry.”
Looking at disruptions along the value chain (table 1), we find that “Demand-driven stockouts” are very frequent, followed by “Disruptions at first-tier suppliers” and “Disruptions in their own operations.”
We identify ‘’Product quality incidents,” “Demand shocks” and “Export/Import restrictions” as the top disruptions. Next to a “Loss in revenue” (67% of companies), companies are penalized with “Customer complaints” (55% of companies) and “Loss of Productivity” (51% of companies) among others.
Pillar 2 – Management Culture
When it comes to the attention of top management, 33% of our survey participants indicate that supply chain resilience is a “High” priority for top management and for a further 27%, it is even considered a “Very high” priority. Table 2 indicates that for 85% of the companies surveyed, the topic has an increased importance either within the entire organization (44%) or in some parts of the organization (41%).
Yet, while companies agree on the importance of the topic, they still lack a best-practice approach for measuring resilience. Qualitative (20%), quantitative (30%) or a mixture of both measures (35%) are close to being equally preferred among survey participants.
Pillar 3 – Procurement
On the procurement side, companies seem to have identified their vulnerability caused by disruptions at first-tier suppliers. They actively dual source their raw material (90% of companies), perform supplier audits (72% of companies) or rate their suppliers (see table 3). 94% of the companies follow long-term and collaborative relationships with their key suppliers.
But, despite these efforts, a strong vulnerability at first-tier suppliers remains (table 1). Efficient risk mitigation strategies call for an increased multi-stakeholder dialogue.
Pillar 4 – Operations
Internally, companies invest in dual/multiple source within the manufacturing process (78% of companies), risk mitigation inventory (on average 21-40 days of inventory for finished goods), or agility capacity (on average 10-15%). These investments reflect the importance of the topic for top management. But when it comes to implementation, only 29% of the companies manage to align the three mitigation strategies holistically (table 4). Further operational mitigation strategies are next to the classic “Cycle time” and “Lead time reduction” also “Production shifting” or “Overtime and subcontracting.”
Pillar 5 – Demand & Visibility
On the demand side, companies focus on visibility-related risk mitigation strategies (e.g. EDI technology or data sharing, see table 5). Consequently, 80% of the companies have “High” or “Medium” visibility on their stockouts; but at the same time only a small proportion of the companies has “High” or “Very High” visibility on safety inventories carried by their distribution partners (40% of companies) or their customers (25% of companies). Additionally, only 22% of the companies have full visibility on the costs for their clients that are caused by their stockouts.
While visibility in their own operations is a good way forward, further visibility must be enhanced on the distribution partner or customer side. In this respect, a logistics leader at a pharmaceutical company remarks:
“The importance of this topic (supply chain resilience) is underestimated by commercial teams and should be part of their skills (need for people development).”
Supply chain resilience is not only about business continuity management. Resilience can also give your company a competitive advantage, as a leading tobacco company mentioned:
“After a disruption that affected the entire industry, we managed to recover quicker than our competitors, and hence gain additional market share.”
While commitment to supply chain resilience is not the whole story, companies still struggle with efficient implementation. To distinguish leaders from laggards, a substantial effort must be put forward as Richard Groenenboom, Head of Supply Chain Capabilities at a large pharma company, reflects:
“Supply Chain Resilience requires a holistic view, the commitment of our entire organization, substantial data collection, development of joint metrics, alignment of processes and ultimately also a significant financial investment to mitigate the identified risks.”
Ralf W. SeifertisProfessor of Operations Management at IMD and directs the DIGITAL SUPPLY CHAIN MANAGEMENT (DSCM)program.
Florian Lücker received his Master’s Degree in Natural Sciences from ETH Zurich. After spending six months with a leading investment bank, he is currently pursuing his PhD at EPFL.
Contact
for additional information on IMD publications
Related topics
Supply Chain
Browse all topics
Related topics
Supply Chain
Browse all topics
Looking for something specific?
IMD's faculty and research teams publish articles, case studies, books and reports on a wide range of topics
All articles
Keep reading
ArticleSupply ChainArtificial Intelligence
Beyond the hype cycle: GenAI use cases in supply chain planningHow can businesses employ large language models in supply chain management?
By Ralf W. SeifertAlberto FabregatandSrinath Goud Vanga
inI by IMD14 March 2024
ArticleSupply Chain
Five supply chain trends for 2024After several years of unprecedented disruption, will 2024 be any easier for supply chain leaders? Almost certainly not.
By Carlos Cordon
inI by IMD31 January 2024
ArticleGlobal BusinessEconomicsSupply Chain
China is the world’s sole manufacturing superpower: A line sketch of the rise
The US is the world’s sole military superpower. It spends more on its military than the ten next highest spending countries combined. China is now ...
By Richard Baldwin
inVoxEU17 January 2024
ArticleSupply ChainStrategy
With a growing number of online retailers now offering to provide third-party logistics to vendors, the boundaries are blurring between e-commerce ...
By Richard MarkoffandRalf W. Seifert
inI by IMD7 December 2023
ArticleSupply ChainSustainability
Strategic energy sourcing in the modern business environmentThe energy landscape has evolved into a complex network of choices and implications for business. What should companies consider when selecting the...
By Salvatore CantaleandAndrea Cantobelli
inI by IMD4 December 2023
ArticleSupply ChainDisruptionGlobal Business
Supply chain disruptions: Shocks, links, and hidden exposure
Supply chain disruptions are routinely blamed for things ranging from elevated inflation to shortages of medical equipment in the pandemic. But how...
By Richard BaldwinRebecca FreemanandAngelos Theodorakopoulos
inVoxEU29 November 2023
ArticleEconomicsSustainabilitySupply Chain
Wie Partnerschaften die Kreislaufwirtschaft vorantreiben
The economy must not only become climate neutral, but also protect supply chains. With the circular economy, ecological and economic goals can be c...
By Julia Katharina BinderandManuel Braun
inFocus Online19 November 2023
ArticleSupply ChainSustainability
Carbon accounting: Learnings from the governance journeyHow companies understand their sustainability-related governance may hold the key to meeting climate goals and thriving in a net-zero economy
By Ralf W. SeifertRichard MarkoffandAlexander Schmidt
inI by IMD16 November 2023
ArticleLeadershipSupply Chain
Vestas CEO: “Failure is always an option” [Video]Henrik Andersen discusses with IMD President Jean-François Manzoni the challenges of navigating supply chain disruptions and soaring raw material c...
By Jean-François Manzoni
inI by IMD14 November 2023
ArticleInnovationStrategySupply ChainChina
Geely: The ever-evolving businessLi Shufu, CEO and founder of Chinese carmaker Geely, overcame a host of setbacks to become the billionaire owner of a multi-faceted business
By Mark J. GreevenandPatrick Reinmoeller
inI by IMD7 November 2023
Beyond the hype cycle: GenAI use cases in supply chain planning
By Ralf W. SeifertAlberto FabregatandSrinath Goud Vanga
inI by IMD14 March 2024
Summary
How can businesses employ large language models in supply chain management?
Read more
Contact
for additional information on IMD publications
Related topics
Supply Chain
Artificial Intelligence
Browse all topics
Five supply chain trends for 2024
By Carlos Cordon
inI by IMD31 January 2024
Summary
After several years of unprecedented disruption, will 2024 be any easier for supply chain leaders? Almost certainly not.
Read more
Contact
for additional information on IMD publications
Related topics
Supply Chain
Browse all topics
China is the world’s sole manufacturing superpower: A line sketch of the rise
By Richard Baldwin
inVoxEU17 January 2024
Summary
The US is the world’s sole military superpower. It spends more on its military than the ten next highest spending countries combined. China is now ...
Contact
for additional information on IMD publications
Related topics
Global Business
Economics
Supply Chain
Browse all topics
In e-commerce, supply chain and business strategy are merging
By Richard MarkoffandRalf W. Seifert
inI by IMD7 December 2023
Summary
With a growing number of online retailers now offering to provide third-party logistics to vendors, the boundaries are blurring between e-commerce ...
Read more
Contact
for additional information on IMD publications
Related topics
Supply Chain
Strategy
Browse all topics
Strategic energy sourcing in the modern business environment
By Salvatore CantaleandAndrea Cantobelli
inI by IMD4 December 2023
Summary
The energy landscape has evolved into a complex network of choices and implications for business. What should companies consider when selecting the...
Read more
Contact
for additional information on IMD publications
Related topics
Supply Chain
Sustainability
Browse all topics
Supply chain disruptions: Shocks, links, and hidden exposure
By Richard BaldwinRebecca FreemanandAngelos Theodorakopoulos
inVoxEU29 November 2023
Summary
Supply chain disruptions are routinely blamed for things ranging from elevated inflation to shortages of medical equipment in the pandemic. But how...
Contact
for additional information on IMD publications
Related topics
Supply Chain
Disruption
Global Business
Browse all topics
Wie Partnerschaften die Kreislaufwirtschaft vorantreiben
By Julia Katharina BinderandManuel Braun
inFocus Online19 November 2023
Summary
The economy must not only become climate neutral, but also protect supply chains. With the circular economy, ecological and economic goals can be c...
Contact
for additional information on IMD publications
Related topics
Economics
Sustainability
Supply Chain
Browse all topics
Carbon accounting: Learnings from the governance journey
By Ralf W. SeifertRichard MarkoffandAlexander Schmidt
inI by IMD16 November 2023
Summary
How companies understand their sustainability-related governance may hold the key to meeting climate goals and thriving in a net-zero economy
Read more
Contact
for additional information on IMD publications
Related topics
Supply Chain
Sustainability
Browse all topics
Vestas CEO: “Failure is always an option” [Video]
By Jean-François Manzoni
inI by IMD14 November 2023
Summary
Henrik Andersen discusses with IMD President Jean-François Manzoni the challenges of navigating supply chain disruptions and soaring raw material c...
Read more
Contact
for additional information on IMD publications
Related topics
Leadership
Supply Chain
Browse all topics
Geely: The ever-evolving business
By Mark J. GreevenandPatrick Reinmoeller
inI by IMD7 November 2023
Summary
Li Shufu, CEO and founder of Chinese carmaker Geely, overcame a host of setbacks to become the billionaire owner of a multi-faceted business
Read more
Contact
for additional information on IMD publications
Related topics
Innovation
Strategy
Supply Chain
China
Browse all topics