As you did your holiday shopping in recent years, you were probably deluged with offers to save money by signing up for a store’s credit card. Sales associates often offer customers a one-time discount of 10-15% for applying. The savings can be tempting if you're making a large purchase, but are store credit cards a good idea in the long run? It depends.
Who doesn't want to be rewarded?
Create a NerdWallet account for personalized recommendations, and find the card that rewards you the most for your spending.
Why you shouldn't sign up
Unfortunately, no matter how good the discount sounds, store credit cards are usually a better deal for the issuer than they are for you. Consider:
The terms. While the average interest rate for an American credit card typically hovers around 15%, those for retail credit cards are usually upwards of 20%. Many also have a lower-than-average credit limit, and some can only be used at the store that issued them.
Your credit score. Every time you apply for a new card, your credit score takes a small hit. If you have good credit otherwise, this may not affect you much, unless you apply for several cards close together. However, your credit may be damaged in other ways. For example, because of their lower credit limits, store cards could drive up your debt-to-credit ratio.
Temptation. You may sign up for a store credit card for savings, but if it leads you to spend more than you intended — either on the day you sign up, or subsequently — is it worth it? If you can’t keep an eye on your purchases as closely with a store credit card as you can without one, you might be better off without.
As always, opening a credit card should not be done on impulse. Review all the factors carefully before deciding whether or not it’s worthwhile; don’t let your sales associate pressure you. After all, would you make any other important financial decisions in a busy check-out line?
🤓Nerdy Tip
Store credit cards will either be "open-loop" or "closed-loop." Open-loop cards function like any other credit card: You'll be able to use it anywhere the payment processor is accepted. Closed-loop cards can only be used at the store issuing you the card.
» MORE: Looking at store cards? You'll likely get more value out of these cards
Why you should sign up
NerdWallet rating
If you’re generally financially responsible — paying your balance in full each month and spending within your means — having a credit card issued by one or two of your favorite stores may not be a bad idea. Many companies offer exclusive discounts or generous financing terms throughout the year to those holding their cards.
The Target Circle™ Credit Card, for example, offers a 5% discount on Target purchases, plus free shipping, exclusive offers and early access to promotions. If you're a frequent Target shopper, those perks give this card long-term value.
NerdWallet rating
Even a one-time discount could save you a lot of money, if you have a large purchase coming up. For people renovating a home or buying a new appliance, the MyLowe’s Rewards Credit Card could be especially useful. New cardholders get 20% off their next purchase. It's capped at $100 in savings, but that's still a good deal if you're about to make a major purchase.
Moreover, if you want to improve your credit, department store cards can be more accessible than other cards. They also add variety to the types of loans you have out, as well as raise your overall credit limit and increase the number of open accounts.
Just be sure not to sign up for cards at too many “favorite” stores. Having many credit accounts increases the risk of overspending if you use them, and the risk of identity theft if you don’t.
🤓Nerdy Tip
Many store cards offer financing options with 0% interest. If you don't have cash for a necessary purchase, this can help you avoid interest, but make sure to look at the terms. A lot of these offers feature deferred interest, so if you don't pay off the entire balance before the financing period ends, you'll be on the hook for interest on the entire purchase — not just on the remaining balance.
There’s no right or wrong answer when it comes to store credit cards. If it’s a bad idea for you to sign up for another card, making it a retail-issued card just makes it worse. But if you have good credit and can take advantage of the discounts that come with the card without going overboard, it might be useful. You may also be better off signing up for a standard rewards card, though, so evaluate all of your options before taking the plunge.
» MORE: Best store credit cards
What's next?
Learn how to make holiday shopping more affordable.
Know how holiday shopping can impact your credit score.
See how your credit card rewards can help you cut costs on holiday shopping.
