How to Invest in Classic Cars - MoneyMade (2024)

When it comes to investing in the transport sector, we usually look to disruptive technologies like flying cars, electric vehicles, and autonomous driving. But what if you invested in a 50-year old gas-guzzler instead? I can already hear you asking me why the hell anyone would do that.

It’s simple, really. Some sought-after collectible cars have appreciated by an average of 20% per year since 2007—blowing past S&P 500 returns. This, plus the fact that you can use it while enjoying these returns, makes it one of the best collectibles to invest in for car enthusiasts. But learning how to invest in cars takes more than just passion.

More on Collectibles

Essentially, “classic” has become an umbrella term for any older car that’s collectible. So this encapsulates other types of collectible cars like vintages and antiques. The 20 to 30-year-old collectible cars, on the other hand, are more properly called modern classics. Does that make sense? Alright, let’s keep cruising.

It almost goes without saying, but for a car to be a “classic” it also has to remain true to its original design (don’t go too crazy, modders) and be in good working order. So if the car’s body deteriorates, the interior is damaged, or the engine doesn’t run, you can fuggedaboutit being a classic.

At some point, I’m sure you’ve heard your gearhead buddies throw around terms like classic, antique, and vintage all the while you nodded along and pretended to follow. Yeah, me too.

These categories are determined by several factors like age, historic status, price, and modifications. But in everyday conversation, classic cars are mostly categorized by age. Here’s how the numbers break down:

• Modern classic cars: 20 years+, manufactured 2000 or earlier
• Vintage cars: 45 years+, manufactured in 1975 or earlier.
• Antique cars: 100 years+, manufactured between 1919 and 1930.

In the most basic sense, classic cars are valued because they're rare or one of a kind. Limited production runs, nostalgic designs, high performance, and special features all play into this.

Here are the 5 main qualities that make classic cars valuable. All things considered, a classic car will command higher prices as it meets more of these qualities.

Age

While classic cars can be anywhere from 20 to 30 years old, older cars tend to fetch higher prices on the market.

Condition

Condition probably plays the most important role in valuation. A classic car that is still aesthetic and runs is always going to be more valuable than one that’s rusty and broken down. Plus points for low mileage, too.

Rarity

The lower the production run and current supply, the more valuable the classic. Even experimental cars that were never commercially released can become coveted. Take the Bugatti Royale, for instance.

Popularity

Classic cars can become popular for a number of reasons, like:

• Appearing in movies, e.g. Delorean DMC-12 in Back to the Future.
• Being associated with celebrities, like Steve McQueen and Paul Newman.
• Having a racing history, e.g. Ferrari 250 Testa Rossa
• Having unique design and performance features for their era. E.g. 1957 Plymouth Belvedere’s space-age design.

Brand

Some models simply command higher prices than others due to the strength of their brand. Ferrari and Chevrolet are two such examples known for their build quality.

Now I know you’re excited and all, but pump the brakes on buying that Mustang for a minute. Let’s consider some of the downsides of owning a classic car, just so you know what you’re getting yourself into.

If you buy a classic car thinking that it’s going to be a passive investment, then you might as well park it in the middle of a drawbridge cause that investment is going under.

Costs

Like many tangible investments, classic cars carry high fees: from restoration and maintenance to storage, insurance. As you well know, cars are vulnerable to theft, vandalism, or accidents (hence the need for insurance).

Aside from this, restoring a classic to the highest degree — also known as Concours condition — can run you anywhere from five to seven figures. And even selling the car will probably incur transaction and transport costs.

Speculation

Trying to predict which cars will end up becoming collectible is a risky game. The car community is littered with stories of early investors who lost money on these bets. In 1976, Cadillac informed the public that it would be producing its last convertible — the 1976 Fleetwood Eldorado.

Investors bought up all the replicas thinking that they were an instant collectible. But Cadillac went ahead and reissued the Eldorado convertible 1984, leading those early buyers to lose half of their investment (they tried suing with no luck).

Systemic risks

This is the risk of an economic collapse that doesn’t have anything to do with the cars, but they are affected nonetheless. Classic cars have been shown to be somewhat correlated with financial markets, with prices falling during crises like the 2008 housing bubble and the 2020 COVID-19 pandemic.

For some expert guidance on the best classic cars to invest in, let’s turn to Hagerty, a classic car insurance company.

Hagerty has developed several indexes that average the values of sought-after classic cars. Their Blue-Chip Index includes the 25 most valuable classics in the world, which collectively are up over 300% since 2007. Today's average price for one of these blue chips is just shy of $3.2 million.

Hagerty also developed the Affordable Classics Index, which includes 12 classics priced under $40,000. This index has also been trending up since 2007, with one the average value of one car currently sitting at $47,000.

Here are a few of the prominent models in these indexes.

Aston Martin DB5

• Year: 1965
• Average value: $857,000
• Concours condition value: $1,350,000
• Last sale: $874,000 on August 13, 2021
• Number produced: N/A
• Claim to fame: 4-liter, triple SU-equipped Marek I-6 engine. Appearance in several James Bond films, starting with Goldfinger (1964)

Mercedes-Benz 300SL

• Year: 1957
• Average value: $1,650,000
• Concours condition value: $2,250,000
• Last sale: $1,352,500 on August 12, 2021
• Number produced: 70
• Claim to fame: Gull-wing door design. One of the fastest production cars in the world at the time.

Chevrolet Corvette

• Year: 1953
• Average value: $210,000
• Concours condition value: $386,000
• Last sale: $196,000 on September 4, 2021
• Number produced: 300
• Claim to fame: Widely known as "America's Sports Car." According to Automotive News, the Corvette is the most popular sports car in history, synonymous with freedom and adventure

Volkswagen Beetle

• Year: 1967
• Average value: $23,100
• Concours condition value: $81,100
• Last sale: $16,500 on September 3, 2021
• Number produced: N/A
• Claim to fame: Often considered to be the most significant car of the 20th century. The longest-running and best-selling car of a single platform ever made.

Ford Mustang GT

• Year: 1965
• Average value: $43,400
• Concours condition value: $82,400
• Last sale: $23,100 on May 19, 2018
• Number produced: 15,106
• Claim to fame: Compact design and sporty performance that has become an icon of American cars.