You Should Never Plant a Butterfly Bush Again - Natural Lands (2024)

Home You Should Never Plant a Butterfly Bush Again

May 1, 2024

By Natural Lands

They’re gorgeous,
but they actually do more harm than good.

You Should Never Plant a Butterfly Bush Again - Natural Lands (1)

ED RESCHKE / GETTY IMAGES

If someone took 75% of yourfoodaway, you wouldn’t be a happy camper. But when you grow invasivebutterfly bushes and other plants that provide only nectar, that’s what you’re doing tobirdsandbutterfliesin your own backyard.

A leading wildlife ecologist wants you to think about your property — no matter how big or small — as an important link in your local ecosystem. Each plant you include in your garden affect the local food web, even the beautiful, seemingly harmless butterfly bush.

Doug Tallamy, PhD, professor and chair of entomology and wildlife ecology at the University of Delaware, revealed three hard truths about butterfly bush — and why you should stop planting them at home.

1. butterfly bush doesn’t stay in your yard

You Should Never Plant a Butterfly Bush Again - Natural Lands (2)

WHITEWAY/ GETTY

Butterfly bush is an invasive plant, meaning it crowds out beneficial plants that have naturally grown in your community for centuries. This species originally from Asia readily takes over space where native North American plants would normally thrive. In fact,Buddleja davidii(the scientific name for butterfly bush) has certain traits that make it invasive in most environments.

“I hear the ‘it’s invasive here, but not over there’ argument a lot,” says Tallamy. “While it is invasive in many parts of the U.S., what’s really important is that the plant has the ability to be invasive almost anywhere. If it’s not in some place, chances are good it will be [at some point].”

Beyond backyards, the plants spread to important ecosystems and protected areas. There’sclear documentationof aggressive butterfly bush invasions in wildlife habitats.

“People who say butterfly bush doesn’t move around are in the denial stage,” Tallamy says. “Butterfly bush just doesn’t stay where we plant it.”

2. butterfly bush doesn’t really benefit butterflies

You Should Never Plant a Butterfly Bush Again - Natural Lands (3)

RAQUEL LONAS/ GETTY

There’s no denying that butterfly bush’s long, narrow tufts of flowers look beautiful. And like many flowering plants, it supplies lots of nectar. But when it’s the only species you grow for butterflies, you’re not going to have butterflies anymore, Tallamy warns.

These insects also require proper host plants so they can reproduce. Their larval offspring have to feed on the leaves of native species like butterfly weed, other milkweeds, joe-pye weed, and oak trees.

“People rationalize their perceived need for butterfly bush because they think it helps butterflies,” Tallamy says. “What they really want is a pretty plant in their yard.”

3. butterfly bush contributes to the collapse of food webs

You Should Never Plant a Butterfly Bush Again - Natural Lands (4)

BIRDIMAGES / GETTY

Here’s the harsh truth: Planting non-native plants like butterfly bush inyour yardactually makes it harder for the butterflies and birds in your neighborhood to survive.

For instance, if you want chickadees to breed in your yard, you need plants that can support the 6,000 to 9,000 caterpillars the birds need during the 16 days they feed their young.

“If you don’t have that, the plant-caterpillar-chickadee food web stops,” Tallamy explains. “If you plant butterfly bush, and not native [species], then right away you’re removing at least 75% of the food that is supporting the biodiversity that’s out there.”

And these critters need all the help they can get.

You Should Never Plant a Butterfly Bush Again - Natural Lands (2024)

FAQs

You Should Never Plant a Butterfly Bush Again - Natural Lands? ›

Butterfly bush is an invasive plant, meaning it crowds out beneficial plants that have naturally grown in your community for centuries. This species originally from Asia readily takes over space where native North American plants would normally thrive.

Why should you never plant a butterfly bush again? ›

Butterfly bushes grow and spread aggressively, often out-competing native plants. This can disrupt local ecosystems and decrease food and habitat availability for beneficial insects and other wildlife.

What are the negatives of butterfly bushes? ›

Butterfly Bush is a problem in the environment in several ways. First, it out-competes native plants, taking up the space they need. Second, because it produces abundant nectar, pollinators often ignore flowers on native plants, depriving them of the pollination they need to reproduce.

Are butterfly bushes banned in some states? ›

It forms thick, shrubby thickets that preclude the development of other native species such as willow. Butterfly bush is considered invasive in many states, as well as England and New Zealand. Some states, like Oregon, have even banned sales of the plant.

Is it OK to plant butterfly bush? ›

Note: Butterfly Bushes have been found to be invasive in some areas and are listed as such on some state invasive plant lists. To avoid this problem, deadhead the flowers religiously, plant Butterfly Bush alternatives that aren't invasive or grow sterile seeded varieties.

What is the lifespan of a butterfly bush? ›

Typically, a butterfly bush will live about 10 years. You may find some plants that live longer than that, but it's a rare case. Proper care of a butterfly bush will help it live longer and thrive in your garden.

What is a good substitute for a butterfly bush? ›

Native substitutes for Butterfly Bush

For sunny, open garden or landscape plantings, try Sweet Pepperbush, also called Summersweet (Clethra alnifolia) or Virginia Sweetspire (Itea virginica). For wetter soils, try Buttonbush (Cephalanthis occidentalis)—a food source for moths—or New Jersey Tea (Ceanothus americanus).

Do butterfly bushes attract mosquitoes? ›

The scientists chose the butterfly bush (Buddleja davidii) for their experiment because it's a very hardy plant that flowers throughout the year, and mosquitoes are attracted to it.

Do hummingbirds like butterfly bushes? ›

As you can imagine, the butterfly bush is famous for attracting butterflies, though hummingbirds enjoy its large, fragrant flowers as well. This perennial can grow five to 12 feet tall and spread four to 15 feet. Blossom colors vary, but pink, purple, red and white are the most common.

Where is the best place to plant a butterfly bush? ›

Butterfly bushes, sometimes called summer lilacs, are recommended for USDA hardiness Zones 5 to 10 and need full sun and fertile, well-drained soil. Dig a hole about twice the diameter of the root ball, and set your plant in the garden no deeper than it was growing in its nursery pot.

Is butterfly bush native or invasive? ›

Buddleja davidii (butterfly bush) is a shrub (family Buddlejaceae) with a cluster of pink to purple flowers and narrow leaves found in the San Francisco Bay area and coastal ranges of California, and is invasive in the Pacific Northwest. It is native to China. It favors riparian and bottomland habitat.

Is butterfly bush toxic to pets? ›

🐶 Butterfly Bush is non-toxic to dogs, but may cause mild GI upset. Symptoms include drooling, vomiting, diarrhea; usually not severe. Prevent ingestion with training, barriers, or offering safe plant alternatives.

How tall does a butterfly bush get? ›

Butterfly bushes come in 2 general categories- a “larger” size that grows between 3 to 5 feet in width and 5 to 10 feet in height and the “dwarf” size that grows between 2 to 4 feet in width and 2 to 4 feet in height.

What are the disadvantages of butterfly bushes? ›

Because butterfly bushes offer copious amounts of nectar, they become extremely attractive to pollinators, distracting them from other native co-flowering species, and reducing the native's reproductive success which eventually also harms the native's populations.

What happens if you don't cut back a butterfly bush? ›

But without regular pruning, butterfly bushes can become sparse, and flowering can diminish, leaving next to nothing for pollinators. So keep pruning to keep the butterflies coming to your garden for years to come!

What month do you plant butterfly bushes? ›

Butterfly bushes do best when planted in early spring or summer, but when the temperatures are hotter keep them well-watered. An island bed planted with a butterfly bush (or several) will help attract these lovely pollinators. Other places to use them include perennial beds and borders and cottage or wildlife gardens.

Can you dig up and replant a butterfly bush? ›

When Can You Transplant Butterfly Bushes? Butterfly bushes are quite hardy and can transplant easily. Transplanting a butterfly bush is usually accomplished in either spring or fall. Transplant prior to new growth in spring or once its foliage has died down in the fall.

Will a dead butterfly bush come back? ›

Butterfly bushes are perennial plants that die back to the ground every winter. They then send out new growth from the roots in the spring. You can prune them either in the late fall or in the early spring before the new growth starts. It is best to prune them back to about 12 inches from the ground.

Do butterfly bushes reseed themselves? ›

Butterfly bushes do best in full sun and sandier soil. Because these plants self-seed readily and spread, they can be considered a weed in some regions so you should plant somewhere with ample space.

Top Articles
3 Tech Stocks That Could Turn $1,000 into $10,000 by 2030
The Future of Credit Repair and Tradelines
7 C's of Communication | The Effective Communication Checklist
Genesis Parsippany
Terrorist Usually Avoid Tourist Locations
Nehemiah 4:1–23
Sissy Hypno Gif
Mcoc Immunity Chart July 2022
Select The Best Reagents For The Reaction Below.
Soap2Day Autoplay
J Prince Steps Over Takeoff
Bbc 5Live Schedule
U.S. Nuclear Weapons Complex: Y-12 and Oak Ridge National Laboratory…
Es.cvs.com/Otchs/Devoted
Unit 1 Lesson 5 Practice Problems Answer Key
Lqse-2Hdc-D
Saw X | Rotten Tomatoes
Hair Love Salon Bradley Beach
Craigslist Apartments In Philly
Me Cojo A Mama Borracha
How pharmacies can help
Vintage Stock Edmond Ok
Tu Pulga Online Utah
Wemod Vampire Survivors
Azur Lane High Efficiency Combat Logistics Plan
Like Some Annoyed Drivers Wsj Crossword
Play Tetris Mind Bender
6 Most Trusted Pheromone perfumes of 2024 for Winning Over Women
Airline Reception Meaning
Restored Republic June 16 2023
Malluvilla In Malayalam Movies Download
The Eight of Cups Tarot Card Meaning - The Ultimate Guide
'Insidious: The Red Door': Release Date, Cast, Trailer, and What to Expect
208000 Yen To Usd
Gopher Carts Pensacola Beach
Taylored Services Hardeeville Sc
Productos para el Cuidado del Cabello Después de un Alisado: Tips y Consejos
Baldur's Gate 3 Dislocated Shoulder
Human Unitec International Inc (HMNU) Stock Price History Chart & Technical Analysis Graph - TipRanks.com
Reli Stocktwits
Selfservice Bright Lending
Car Crash On 5 Freeway Today
Babylon 2022 Showtimes Near Cinemark Downey And Xd
Restored Republic June 6 2023
Craigslist Odessa Midland Texas
Craigslist Farm And Garden Reading Pa
Former Employees
Oklahoma City Farm & Garden Craigslist
Frequently Asked Questions
CPM Homework Help
Aaca Not Mine
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Frankie Dare

Last Updated:

Views: 5415

Rating: 4.2 / 5 (73 voted)

Reviews: 80% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Frankie Dare

Birthday: 2000-01-27

Address: Suite 313 45115 Caridad Freeway, Port Barabaraville, MS 66713

Phone: +3769542039359

Job: Sales Manager

Hobby: Baton twirling, Stand-up comedy, Leather crafting, Rugby, tabletop games, Jigsaw puzzles, Air sports

Introduction: My name is Frankie Dare, I am a funny, beautiful, proud, fair, pleasant, cheerful, enthusiastic person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.