What is Quiet Firing | How To Identify And Prevent It (2024)

The concept of "quiet firing," also known as silent firing, has emerged as a concern that warrants careful consideration.

According to a LinkedIn News poll, the widespread nature of this practice is evident.

More than 80% of participants indicated that they have either personally experienced or directly observed instances of subtle dismissals.

Some companies believe that quiet firing may be advantageous, since voluntary resignations exempt employees from severance or unemployment compensation.

However, the reality is that this approach can be detrimental to business for various reasons.

The catch is that while quiet firing is intentional most of the time, there is a possibility that sometimes organizations might do it without realizing it.

Recognizing the signs and understanding the implications of quiet firing is essential for both HR professionals and companies as a whole.

What is quiet firing?

Quiet firing is an insidious practice wherein a company encourages an employee to leave without explicit termination.

It involves subtle signals, such as denied salary increases, delayed promotions, and a dearth of constructive feedback.

Addressing quiet firing isn't a straightforward solution, but HR can take various approaches, including conducting diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) training, cultivating open communication, and refining performance evaluation processes.

Each of these strategies contributes to combating a hostile work environment creating a healthier and more transparent work environment.

Quiet firing can also happen in a myriad of other ways. They can be a combination of the following scenarios.-

• Isolation or exclusion from team activities, meetings, social events and decision-making processes, signaling a deliberate distancing by the organization.

• Reduction in responsibilities without valid explanations, leaving the employee with less meaningful work to do.

• Marginalization in meetings where the employee’s contributions are consistently overlooked or dismissed in team meetings or discussions.

• Sudden heightened levels of criticism, scrutiny, or micromanagement from supervisors or managers, contributing to feelings of alienation and frustration.

• An unexpected shift in performance standards or expectations that seem unattainable or arbitrary.

• A gradual withdrawal of privileges or perks that were once enjoyed by the employee ( for example - access to professional development opportunities, company events, or other benefits that contribute to employee engagement and morale)

• Sudden changes to an employee's structure such as - schedule, location, or working conditions.

For example, They may be moved to a different department, assigned to a less desirable shift, or required to work remotely without prior fair consultation or explanation.

These underhanded tactics are designed to create an environment that prompts the employee to consider alternative career paths without the need for direct confrontation or termination.

Why quiet firings happen instead of proper termination

The decision to engage in quiet firing reflects a complex interplay of organizational priorities and strategies. Here are a few reasons as to why companies engage in it.

1. To reduce costs - During periods of financial strain or restructuring, companies may opt for quiet firing to reduce costs associated with severance packages and legal proceedings.
2. To avoid conflict - Quiet firing allows companies to avoid confrontational situations associated with traditional terminations, preserving workplace harmony and avoiding negative publicity.
3. For strategic realignment - In scenarios where organizational goals or priorities shift, quiet firing may be used to realign the workforce with new strategic objectives.It enables companies to recalibrate team compositions and skill sets without attracting undue attention.
4. To avoid legal risks - Quiet firing minimizes the risk of potential legal disputes or wrongful termination claims that may arise from explicit termination decisions.

How does quiet firing affect companies?

Quiet firing can indeed have profound effects on companies, extending beyond the immediate impact on the individuals involved.

Here are several ways in which quiet firing affects companies.

1. Quiet firing can foster a culture of mistrust, resentment, and secrecy within the workplaceEmployees may become disillusioned with the organization's leadership and lose confidence in its commitment to fairness and transparency.Employees who witness or experience quiet firing may become disengaged from their work and the organization as a whole.They may feel undervalued, expendable, or unsupported, leading to decreased motivation and productivity.
2. Quiet firing can erode team morale and cohesion as employees become aware of the subtle tactics used to encourage departuresTrust among team members may be compromised, and collaboration may suffer as individuals become focused on self-preservation rather than collective success.The presence of quiet firing can disrupt workflows and hinder productivity as employees grapple with uncertainty and distractions related to their employment status.The fear of being targeted for quiet firing may also discourage employees from taking initiative or voicing innovative ideas.
3. Loss of good talent, damaged reputation, and legal repercussionsOrganizations that engage in quiet firing may experience higher attrition rates as disillusioned employees seek opportunities elsewhere.The loss of talent can be detrimental to the company's long-term success, as valuable knowledge and expertise are depleted, and recruitment costs escalate.Employees who feel they have been unfairly targeted for quiet firing may pursue legal action for wrongful termination, discrimination, or retaliation, resulting in costly litigation and reputational damage.The reputation of the company as an employer of choice may suffer due to perceptions of unfair treatment and lack of transparency surrounding quiet firing practices.Negative word-of-mouth from current and former employees can deter prospective talent from considering employment opportunities with the organization.

How unintentional quiet firing happens and how to prevent it

Unintentional quiet firing can occur due to various factors, often stemming from poor communication, lack of clarity, or unconscious biases within the company. Here are some ways it might happen.

Lack of feedback and unequal opportunities make employees feel subtly pushed out of the organization

When HR and managers fail to provide regular, constructive feedback to employees about their performance, career development, or areas for improvement, it can lead to feelings of ambiguity and uncertainty on the part of the employee.

In environments where certain employees receive more opportunities for advancement, recognition, or challenging assignments compared to others, unintentional quiet firing can occur.

This disparity in treatment may not be immediately apparent but can lead to feelings of disengagement and disillusionment among those who feel overlooked or undervalued.

How to prevent it

In order to mitigate this, HRs should prioritize regular performance evaluations and feedback sessions to provide constructive guidance for employee development.

Clear criteria for career advancement and transparent processes for promotions should also be established to mitigate disparities in opportunities.

Organizational changes and implicit biases can lead to unintentional quiet firing

During periods of organizational change, such as mergers, acquisitions, or restructuring, employees may inadvertently become casualties of shifting priorities or unclear expectations.

Lack of communication about the impact of these changes on individual roles and career paths can create an atmosphere of uncertainty and disengagement, potentially leading to quiet firing scenarios.

Unconscious biases held by managers or decision-makers within the company may influence perceptions of employee performance, potential, or cultural fit.

These biases can result in unequal treatment or opportunities, ultimately contributing to unintentional quiet firing by creating barriers to advancement or recognition for certain individuals.

How to prevent it

HR should prioritize open and transparent communication with employees during organizational changes. Employees should have clarity about roles, expectations, and career paths within the new structure.

Implementing diversity and inclusion initiatives and diversity training is crucial to raising awareness of unconscious biases and fostering a culture of fairness, equity, and respect for all employees.

Also, HR should encourage managers and decision-makers to introspect their biases, promoting empathy, understanding, and inclusivity in their interactions and decision-making processes.

There you have it!

Recognizing the signs of quiet firing and understanding its implications is the first step towards fostering a fair and supportive workplace environment.

HR professionals can play a pivotal role in creating a positive and equitable workplace culture that values transparency, fairness, and employee development.

Proper HR intervention at the right times decreases the likelihood of unintentional quiet firing and it promotes the long-term success of both employees and the company.

Thank you for reading and do subscribe - we’ll be psyched to have you!

About Zappyhire

Zappyhire is an AI-powered recruitment automation platform with a built-in ATS, designed for mid-sized companies to large enterprises, with tens of thousands of users around the globe.

Zappyhire smoothly combines end-to-end automation, data intelligence, and a superior user experience for both recruiters and candidates, throughout the recruitment process.

From posting jobs and scheduling interviews to making the final offer and pre-onboarding, Zappyhire ensures efficiency, accuracy and ease at every step.