What are the benefits and drawbacks of using derivatives in risk management? (2024)

One of the main benefits of using derivatives in risk management is hedging, which means reducing or eliminating the exposure to an unfavorable change in the value of an asset or a liability. For example, if you own a portfolio of stocks, you can use a put option to protect yourself from a sharp decline in the market. A put option gives you the right, but not the obligation, to sell a certain amount of stocks at a predetermined price within a specified period. If the market price falls below the strike price, you can exercise the option and limit your losses. If the market price rises above the strike price, you can let the option expire and enjoy the gains.

Another benefit of using derivatives in risk management is speculation, which means taking advantage of an expected change in the value of an asset or a liability. For example, if you expect the interest rate to rise in the future, you can use a futures contract to lock in a higher rate for borrowing or lending money. A futures contract is an agreement to buy or sell a certain amount of an asset at a predetermined price on a specific date. If the interest rate rises above the futures price, you can profit from the difference. If the interest rate falls below the futures price, you can limit your losses by closing the contract before the expiration date.

One of the main drawbacks of using derivatives in risk management is complexity, which means that the terms and conditions of the contracts may be difficult to understand, monitor, and execute. For example, if you use a swap to exchange cash flows with another party based on different interest rates, currencies, or indexes, you may face challenges in measuring and managing the swap value, duration, and risk exposure. A swap is a contract that allows two parties to exchange periodic payments based on different underlying factors. If the swap is not properly structured, valued, or accounted for, you may incur unexpected losses or liabilities.

Another drawback of using derivatives in risk management is leverage, which means that the contracts may amplify the potential gains or losses from a small change in the value of the underlying asset or liability. For example, if you use a margin account to trade derivatives, you may borrow money from your broker to increase your buying power and exposure. A margin account is an account that allows you to trade derivatives with a fraction of the full value of the contract as collateral. If the market moves in your favor, you can earn a higher return on your investment. If the market moves against you, you may lose more than your initial deposit and face a margin call.

A further drawback of using derivatives in risk management is counterparty risk, which means that the contracts may involve the risk of default or non-performance by the other party. For example, if you use an over-the-counter (OTC) derivative, you may rely on the creditworthiness and reputation of the other party to honor the contract. An OTC derivative is a contract that is privately negotiated and traded between two parties, without the intermediation of an exchange or a clearinghouse. If the other party fails to meet its obligations, you may suffer a loss or a delay in receiving your payments.

A final drawback of using derivatives in risk management is market instability, which means that the contracts may contribute to or exacerbate the volatility and unpredictability of the financial markets. For example, if you use a derivative to hedge or speculate, you may affect the supply and demand of the underlying asset or liability, and create price distortions or bubbles. Moreover, if you use a derivative to leverage or arbitrage, you may create systemic risk or contagion, and trigger a chain reaction of losses or failures across the market participants. Therefore, using derivatives in risk management requires caution and regulation to prevent or mitigate the negative externalities.

This is a space to share examples, stories, or insights that don’t fit into any of the previous sections. What else would you like to add?

Economics

+ Follow

Thanks for your feedback

Your feedback is private. Like or react to bring the conversation to your network.