Tape Backup vs. Disk Backup: Which Is Right for Your Business? (2024)

Today, many companies choose to backup their data primarily in the cloud, as it’s relatively inexpensive and easy. Azure Blob Storage, for example, is exceptionally scalable, durable, and feature-rich. However, as secure as cloud storage is, it’s not completely attack-proof. As more cybercriminals are targeting backups first before launching a ransomware attack, we always recommend having more than one backup solution.

Apart from the cloud backups, you can go with a tape or a disk, and each has its pros and cons. In this blog, I’ll spell them out and try to give good use cases for each.

Storage Media — Tape vs. Disk

The primary difference between the two forms of backup is the media onto which your data is backed up. Tape backup provides the ability to copy data packages from a hard drive to a tape cartridge for storage, backup, and recovery purposes in the event of a computer crash or other failure. Disk backup, on the other hand, requires the use of a hard drive or a server.

Tape vs. Disk Backup — Advantages and Disadvantages

Tape Backup vs. Disk Backup: Which Is Right for Your Business? (1)

Don’t write tape off right away. Many businesses still use it, and for good reason!

Advantages of Tape

Tape has been around for a long, long time. So you probably won’t have to make any major infrastructure improvements to use it effectively. Because it’s not linked to your infrastructure, it’s not vulnerable to ransomware, and you can store quite a lot of data in a relatively small device. It also doesn’t require ongoing energy use, and it’s fairly cheap and easy to store offsite.

Remember — even though cybersecurity incidents grab headlines, your workplace could also experience a natural disaster, like a flood or fire. An offsite backup may be critical to a successful IT Disaster Recovery Plan.

Disadvantages of Tape

Writing to tape and reading from it takes a lot longer; it’s not an automated process, and there’s always a chance of data corruption. And if you ever need to restore your data from a tape, you’ll need to go through a series of precise, hands-on steps to make that happen.

There’s also always a chance that someone could simply walk away with a tape or lose one.

Advantages of Disk

Tape Backup vs. Disk Backup: Which Is Right for Your Business? (2)

Generally speaking, disk systems back up much faster than tape, in part because they can do data de-duplication, which means they won’t copy data already stored on the backup appliance. Disk backups are also much easier to access.

Because disk systems use metadata, you can restore your data from any point in time — from individual files to complete images. Backup images can also be mounted on your backup appliance/server for faster recovery in a time of need, which works well for disaster recovery testing and data validation.

And while it used to be true that disks often lacked the capacity of tape, that’s no longer such a clear drawback. Now, a disk backup can store much more on an individual device.

Disadvantages of Disk

It’s harder to safely and securely store servers and hard drives offsite without using a third-party provider, which can add to the cost. However, disk backup solutions are getting cheaper all the time.

Disk storage can also use up a lot of energy, and they can take up more space.

Tape vs. Disk — What Is Best for Your Backup?

For most businesses, the easy answer is probably disk, largely because the backup process can be automatic, and using a disk backup to restore critical systems and data is fast and less labor-intensive. In the unlikely event that you ever have to use your backup, every second counts!

However, if your business is heavily regulated — or for companies that have to maintain files for a very long period of time — tape provides additional protection against cybercrime and can make long-term storage easier and more cost-effective. In fact, large cloud storage providers are some of the most common users of tape storage today. Tape backups are also frequently used by financial, law enforcement, higher education institutions, medical research organizations, and more.

The Best Way To Prevent a Tech-Related Disaster

Tape Backup vs. Disk Backup: Which Is Right for Your Business? (3)

At Marco, we’re all about prevention, but prevention can be hard to advocate for. Many small to midsize businesses tend to underestimate how vulnerable they are to a cyberattack, and it’s always tempting to budget for upgrades that can add more tangible ROI.

Unfortunately, we’ve seen first-hand what happens to businesses that don’t invest in prevention, and it’s not pretty. For small businesses without enough IT staff to keep on top of rapidly evolving security threats, the easiest way to never have to worry about these things again is to invest in managed IT.

Managed IT services offer a number of benefits aside from helping protect your business from a disaster, and fortunately, there’s real ROI attached. Click the link below to learn more.

Tape Backup vs. Disk Backup: Which Is Right for Your Business? (4)

Topics: Business IT Services

Tape Backup vs. Disk Backup: Which Is Right for Your Business? (2024)

FAQs

Tape Backup vs. Disk Backup: Which Is Right for Your Business? ›

Generally speaking, disk-based backup is significantly quicker and more reliable for data restoration than tape-based backup. Instead of writing from disk (such as your hard drives or servers) to a tape, a disk-to-disk backup is simply a more efficient method of data transfer.

Do companies still use tape backup? ›

Did you know that magnetic tapes are still used for backing up storage in 2024? Find out how large and small businesses are using them to protect their valuable data.

Why would an enterprise choose to use tapes for backups rather than hard drives? ›

There are several reasons why. Long used as a lower cost, reliable, and secure option for storing cold data (not commonly accessed or used regularly), backup tape storage is still a part of many organizations' data storage and backup strategy.

What is the difference between disk and tape backup? ›

Performance-wise, tape infrastructure can result in slower data retrieval times, making tape suitable for archival storage where fast access is less critical. Disk storage, with its fast random access speed, is ideal for applications requiring quick data retrieval.

Why tape is still the best way to backup data? ›

Tapes last up to thirty years, which is a significant advantage in the long-term archiving of data. For disaster recovery, tape backup is a reliable and safe option. It offers a backup solution to restore your data in a disaster such as cyber-attacks, fires, or floods.

What is a drawback of tape backups? ›

Tapes also suffer from some of the expected shortcomings of older technologies. Reading from and writing to tapes takes longer than other backup methods. There is a higher chance of data corruption or problems reading data from tapes than, say, disk-based backup.

Is tape backup reliable? ›

Tape backup offers a reliable and cost-effective solution for long-term archival storage, exceeding even the lifespan of most hard drives or cloud storage contracts.

What is the most important difference between a disk and a tape? ›

While disks can be read from any point, tapes provide linear storage, so they need to be wound at the correct point. This makes it much harder to find specific data, especially if you are trying to only restore a specific database or item, making a recovery even slower.

Is tape more reliable than HDD? ›

High Reliability

"Tape storage is troublesome and requires great care." Many people may have this impression about tape storage. However, tape storage today has a lower failure rate and lower risks of data loss caused by blackouts, crashes, or virus attacks, etc. than HDD storage.

How long do backup tapes last? ›

Most manufacturers estimate that LTO tapes will provide dependable data storage for 15-30 years. However, LTO archives require precise storage conditions. Slight deviations in temperature or humidity can affect storage life. Ideally, LTOs should be stored at 61 to 77°F (16 to 25°C).

What is the biggest disadvantage of using tape drives? ›

Some drawbacks of tape technology include the following: Sequential storage. Tape drives use a sequential access approach to reading and writing data. That means they must start at the beginning of the tape and roll through it to access specific data or write new data.

What are the disadvantages of data tape? ›

Obsolescence isn't the only time-critical threat to tape backup, either: tape also degrades over time. If not stored properly, it's subject to oxidation, and uneven stresses could stretch or distort it. Its magnetic properties are susceptible to decline too.

What is the alternative to backup to tape? ›

Cloud backup represents a significant shift from traditional tape drive backup alternatives. Offering scalability and remote data storage, cloud backup solutions appeal to businesses seeking flexibility and off-site data protection.

Is magnetic tape data storage still used? ›

Companies still use tape in state-of-the-art data centers, but engineers developed the underlying tech before the advent of computers. Who said an old dog can't learn new tricks? Despite the age of tape storage technology, innovation continues.

Do computers still use tape? ›

Computers still use magnetic tape as storage, for archival and backup purposes. You just won't find it in a home computer. The main reason it's not more widely spread is that it's extremely slow when it comes to accessing specific files.

Top Articles
Convert binary to string using Python - GeeksforGeeks
SVB crisis: What lesson crypto investors can learn from US banks fallout? | Stock Market News
Hotels Near 6491 Peachtree Industrial Blvd
Joi Databas
55Th And Kedzie Elite Staffing
Jackerman Mothers Warmth Part 3
Myexperience Login Northwell
Celebrity Extra
Atvs For Sale By Owner Craigslist
Pickswise the Free Sports Handicapping Service 2023
Produzione mondiale di vino
Assets | HIVO Support
Koop hier ‘verloren pakketten’, een nieuwe Italiaanse zaak en dit wil je ook even weten - indebuurt Utrecht
Dumb Money
Scholarships | New Mexico State University
Cooking Fever Wiki
“In my day, you were butch or you were femme”
Cvs Appointment For Booster Shot
Craigslist Edmond Oklahoma
Jackson Stevens Global
Golden Abyss - Chapter 5 - Lunar_Angel
50 Shades Of Grey Movie 123Movies
Fort Mccoy Fire Map
Popular Chinese Restaurant in Rome Closing After 37 Years
Craigslist Lewes Delaware
The Largest Banks - ​​How to Transfer Money With Only Card Number and CVV (2024)
8005607994
Caring Hearts For Canines Aberdeen Nc
8000 Cranberry Springs Drive Suite 2M600
Ficoforum
Dr. Nicole Arcy Dvm Married To Husband
Bj타리
Bend Missed Connections
24 Hour Drive Thru Car Wash Near Me
R3Vlimited Forum
Netherforged Lavaproof Boots
Froedtert Billing Phone Number
Craigslist Pets Plattsburgh Ny
US-amerikanisches Fernsehen 2023 in Deutschland schauen
Tricia Vacanti Obituary
Gotrax Scooter Error Code E2
Wgu Admissions Login
Fluffy Jacket Walmart
The Average Amount of Calories in a Poke Bowl | Grubby's Poke
Strange World Showtimes Near Marcus La Crosse Cinema
tampa bay farm & garden - by owner "horses" - craigslist
Craigslist Pet Phoenix
Coleman Funeral Home Olive Branch Ms Obituaries
Jovan Pulitzer Telegram
Texas 4A Baseball
Supervisor-Managing Your Teams Risk – 3455 questions with correct answers
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Fredrick Kertzmann

Last Updated:

Views: 6477

Rating: 4.6 / 5 (66 voted)

Reviews: 81% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Fredrick Kertzmann

Birthday: 2000-04-29

Address: Apt. 203 613 Huels Gateway, Ralphtown, LA 40204

Phone: +2135150832870

Job: Regional Design Producer

Hobby: Nordic skating, Lacemaking, Mountain biking, Rowing, Gardening, Water sports, role-playing games

Introduction: My name is Fredrick Kertzmann, I am a gleaming, encouraging, inexpensive, thankful, tender, quaint, precious person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.