Post
Jan 16 2024 #esg, #human-rights, #social, #supply-chain
NGO National Consumers League recently filed a lawsuit against Starbucks alleging that the company’s marketing touting the ethical sourcing of its coffee and tea is false and misleading. Starbucks backs its ethical sourcing claims through its C.A.F.E. program and third-party verification such as the Rainforest Alliance. However, the lawsuit cites multiple journalistic and regulatory reports alleging that human rights abuses are still occurring at Starbucks’s supplier farms including child labor, forced labor, and sexual abuse. The complaint argues that the stamps and seals provided by verification systems cannot justify ethical sourcing claims, stating that:
“Even if Starbucks purchases 100% of its coffee products from C.A.F.E. Practices-certified coffee farms and 100% of its tea products from tea farms certified by the Rainforest Alliance, this does not render its representations that it is committed to 100% ethical sourcing truthful or non-misleading to consumers.”
While the lawsuit is in its initial stages, some lessons can be drawn from the complaint. For one, it shows the difficulty of identifying and rooting out human rights abuses in a company supply chain which we’ve highlighted for instance in a guest blog here. It is also a warning against making absolute claims about something of which you cannot be absolutely certain.
Starbucks’ labels appear on their products stating “Commitment to 100% Ethical Sourcing.” It’s fair to argue that a reasonable consumer could interpret that as meaning that all Starbucks products are ethically sourced. Supply chain tracing and human rights audits are inherently imperfect; therefore claiming 100% ethical sourcing may be unwise. Instead, companies should only market what they can guarantee. A company can tout its commitment and efforts to improve human rights, without making statements that it cannot guarantee are true.
If you aren’t already subscribed to our complimentary ESG blog, sign up here:https://practicalesg.com/subscribe/for daily updates delivered right to you.
Photo credit: Sundry Photography – stock.adobe.com
The Editor
Zachary Barlow is a licensed attorney. He earned his JD from the University of Mississippi and has a bachelor’s in Public Policy Leadership. He practiced law at a mid-size firm and handled a wide variety of cases. During this time he assisted in overseeing compliance of a public entity and litigated contract disputes, gaining experience both in and outside of the courtroom. Zachary currently assists the PracticalESG.com editorial team by providing research and creating content on a spectrum of ESG… View Profile
Related Posts
Jun 7 2024 #esg, #human-rights, #investors, #social, #supply-chain
Mondelez, JPMorgan Chase CAHRA Proposal Results Wildly Divergent
We wrote recently about shareholder proposals filed with Mondelez and JP Morgan Chase seeking the companies to undertake various efforts related to CAHRAs (Conflict-Affected and High Risk Areas) – a term out of the OECDDue Diligence Guidance for Responsible Supply...
Jun 7 2024 #compliance, #esg, #investors
Do ESG Ratings Carry Litigation Risks?
ESG ratings have been the subject of controversy for some time. Notorious for their inconsistency across raters, opaque proprietary methodologies, and questionable performance indicators, ESG ratings have been thoroughly criticized on multiple fronts. However, that hasn’t stopped investors and other...
Jun 7 2024 #climate, #environment, #esg
WAY More than a Day Late and a Dollar Short
A long, long time ago (2009) in a galaxy far, far away (COP15 in Copenhagen), developed countries committed to a collective goal of raising $100 billion per year by 2020 for climate action in developing countries. The goal was formalized...
Jun 6 2024 #diversity, #equity, #esg, #human-rights, #social
Three Questions to Ask This Pride Month
June is Pride Month, an annual celebration of the many contributions of the LGBTQIA+ community to history and society. Pride is celebrated in June to commemorate its roots in the Stonewall riots of June 1969, which catapulted the Gay Rights...