Internet Explorer 11 (IE11) is not supported. For the best experience please open using Chrome, Firefox, Safari or MS Edge
Product liability refers to the legal responsibility imposed on a manufacturer, distributor, or seller for producing or selling a defective product that causes injury or harm to a consumer.
What is Product liability?
Product liability refers to the legal responsibility imposed on a manufacturer, distributor, or seller for producing or selling a defective product that causes injury or harm to a consumer.
This concept is a cornerstone of consumer protection law. It is designed to ensure that products meet specific safety standards and that faulty or dangerous products do not put consumers at risk.
In Irish law, product liability is governed by the Liability for Defective Products Act 1991, which implements the European Directive 85/374/EEC. This Act provides a framework for establishing liability and seeking compensation in cases where a defective product has caused harm.
Intangible product liability
The concept of product liability is not limited to physical products. It can also apply to intangible products, such as software or digital content, and to services that result in a physical product, such as home construction or car repair.
Defective products
A product is considered defective if it does not provide the safety that a person is entitled to expect. This expectation considers factors such as the presentation of the product, its use, and the time when it was put into circulation.
A product cannot be considered defective solely because a better product is subsequently put into circulation.
In Irish law, a defect can arise in the product's design, manufacturing process, or instructions or warnings that accompany the product. If any of these elements are flawed in a way that makes the product unsafe, it may be considered defective.
Liability for defective products in Ireland
In Irish law, the Liability for Defective Products Act 1991 establishes a system of strict liability for defective products. This means that a manufacturer can be liable for a defective product even if they were not negligent and did not know it was flawed.
The Act applies to all producers of finished products, producers of parts, and importers into the European Union. It also applies to any person who presents as a producer by putting their name, trademark, or other distinguishing feature on the product.
How to establish product liability
Establishing product liability is a crucial process in legal claims involving defective products. In Irish law, the onus is on the party bringing a claim to demonstrate specific vital elements to hold a manufacturer or supplier accountable for any harm caused by a product.
This process is particularly significant in cases relating to personal injury, breach of warranty, or breach of contract due to defective products. Here's a step-by-step guide on how to establish product liability.
Evidence of a defective product
The first step in a product liability claim is to prove that the product in question was indeed defective. This defect might pertain to the design, manufacturing process, or inadequate warnings and instructions. The plaintiff can substantiate this claim through various means, such as:
- Expert testimony: An expert can analyse the product and provide a professional opinion on why it's considered defective
- Safety standards comparison: Demonstrating that the product does not meet the established safety standards
- Performance comparison: Comparing the product's performance with similar products to highlight deficiencies
In some instances, under the consumer expectation test, a defect may be presumed if the product fails to provide the safety that a regular consumer would generally expect.
Proof of harm
The second step involves proving that the plaintiff suffered harm from the defective product. This harm can range from physical injury or damage to property, and can extend to psychological harm in certain situations. The plaintiff must establish:
- Nature of harm detailing the specific injury or damage incurred
- Direct causation directly links the harm and the product's defect. This is crucial in distinguishing the injury as a consequence of the defect and not due to external factors
Causal link between defect and harm
This step establishes a causal relationship between the product's defect and the harm suffered. It requires a clear demonstration that the defect was the direct cause of the injury or damage. This link is fundamental in a product liability claim and can be substantiated through:
- Providing a timeline that aligns the use of the product with the occurrence of harm
- Ruling out other potential causes of the damage to reinforce the argument that the defect was the sole contributor
What are the key considerations in establishing product liability?
When establishing product liability, several critical factors exist beyond the primary proof of defect and causation. These factors, unique to Irish law, play a significant role in determining the outcome of a product liability case.
They include the strict liability regime, the role of warning labels, and the concept of contributory negligence. Each of these elements adds a layer of complexity to how product liability is assessed and determined in legal proceedings.
Strict liability regime
Under the strict liability regime in Irish law, the burden of proving fault or negligence is removed from the plaintiff.
Once a product is shown to be defective and caused harm, the producer is held liable without further proof of negligence. This principle significantly streamlines the legal process for plaintiffs in product liability cases.
Role of warning labels
The presence and adequacy of warning labels on a product can critically affect judgments regarding the product's safety.
A product without sufficient warning labels or instructions could be considered defective, influencing liability decisions. This aspect underscores the importance of clear and comprehensive communication from manufacturers to consumers.
Contributory negligence
In product liability claims, contributory negligence involves examining whether the plaintiff's actions played a part in the harm they suffered.
If it is found that the plaintiff contributed to their harm, this could reduce the producer's liability or negate it altogether, depending on the extent of the plaintiff's contribution.
Product liability insurance and legal action
For manufacturers and suppliers, having product liability insurance is crucial as it provides coverage in the event of legal claims. Conversely, plaintiffs should be prepared for a thorough legal process, often involving extensive evidence gathering and expert testimonies.
What are the three most common defences against product liability claims?
There are several defences that a producer can raise in response to a product liability claim. These include:
- The development risk defence
- The compliance with mandatory regulations defence, and
- The misuse of product defence
These defences allow the producer to avoid liability if they can show that:
- The defect was not foreseeable when the product was put into circulation
- The product complied with mandatory regulations, or
- The consumer misused it in a way that caused harm
Development risk defence
The development risk defence allows a producer to avoid liability if they can show that the state of scientific and technical knowledge at the time the product was put into circulation was not as advanced enough to enable the existence of the defect to be discovered.
This defence reflects that producers often operate at the cutting edge of technology and that it may not always be possible to foresee and prevent every potential defect.
Compliance with mandatory regulations defence
Compliance with mandatory regulations allows a producer to avoid liability if they can show that the product conforms to compulsory rules issued by the relevant public authorities.
This defence recognises that producers who comply with government regulations should not be penalised if those regulations are inadequate.
Misuse of product defence
The misuse of product defence allows a producer to avoid liability if they can show that the consumer misused the product in a way that caused harm.
This defence reflects the principle that consumers are also responsible for using products safely and reasonably.
What is the compensation for product liability?
If a producer is found liable for a defective product, they may be required to compensate the injured party. This can include compensation for personal injury, damage to property, and loss of income.
The amount of compensation will depend on the severity of the harm, the extent of the defect, and the case circ*mstances.
Understanding the implications of product liability claims
Product liability is a complex area of law that serves a vital role in protecting consumers from defective products. It holds manufacturers, distributors, and sellers accountable for the safety of their products and provides a means for consumers to seek compensation when a defective product harms them.
While the principles of product liability are straightforward, applying them in practice can be challenging. Each case is unique and requires a careful analysis of the facts, the product, and the harm suffered.
With the proper legal guidance, consumers can navigate the complexities of product liability law and seek the compensation they deserve.
The content of this article is provided for information purposes only and does not constitute legal or other advice.
Visit our Legislation Hub
