Where was it said that the titans were as strong as weak demigods?? Also, Percy lost to Polybutees??? Umm... why do you think Jason had to save him in the first place? Ik I butchered that. Also, please give me the achievements of his that could not have happened without Annabeth. Who's side are you arguing for? This is a fight strictly for Percy and Thalia and you're mostly talking about how Percy would win except now you're arguing on Thalia's side? Also, did you forget that Percy can control more than just water? If you're talking about him being able to control blood, forget it. He said he wouldn't ever do it again. Also, even if Jason is roughly equal to Thalia, Thalia is a hunter and has more experience than Jason. She beat Luke, who is arguably the best sword fighter of their century, in a duel. She can use a bow and is more agile than Percy. Nico himself said, after meeting Jason, that Percy was the most powerful demigod he'd met. That's true, but power, skill, and intelligence all play a key factor in a fight. Thalia's the daughter of the strongest god, and has similar power levels to Percy. If it was a battle of who was more powerful, then Percy would win. However it's not. They are even in blade combat and Thalia is more agile and is very talented with a bow. And Thalia is smarter at strategizing. Percy may be a good leader, but he lacks strategy. If Percy uses his water powers, it would just be a better conductor for Thalia's lightning. Remind me of how Jason beat Percy, or when. Eidolon fight don't count bc they were not in full control of their actions. That is true, but the ghosts weren't holding back either. The Eidolon's aren't stupid. Gaea told them that they could keep their bodies and they did everything in their power/arsenal to do so. Plus, Jason won, and I just said Thalia is more powerful than Jason.
Also also, Aries's mind was murky? Umm... hello, does the whole Kronos plot not make sense to you? Does the whole "giving Percy the masterbolt because Kronos is influencing" me not make sense? Bruh, seems like you might have been really sleepy, drunk, or high while reading some of the books lmao. Throwing insults doesn't mean you're right btw. I do agree Percy would probably win, but there is definitely a case to be made for Thalia. I could definitely see her winning.
