On Compassion and Cruelty: A Brief Reflection on Proverbs 12:10 — Transform (2024)

Articles

Written By Richard M. Blaylock, PhD

On Compassion and Cruelty: A Brief Reflection on Proverbs 12:10 — Transform (1)

At first blush, Proverbs 12:10 may strike readers as a straightforward verse that provides little to reflect upon. The text may be translated, “A righteous man cares for the life of his beast, but the compassion of the wicked is cruel.”

To many, the verse stands out as a simple call to care for animals. Thus, some have even used the verse to advocate for causes such as veganism and animal rights. Though such readings of Prov 12:10 may seem plausible at first, I would like to suggest that they actually fail to reckon with the profundity of this little proverb.

Despite initial appearances, Prov 12:10 is not primarily about animals (and it is certainly not a call for veganism). Such becomes clear from attending to the parallelism within the proverb.

As is well known, most of biblical proverbs are written in the form of a parallelism, which is a literary convention in which two or more lines of text are brought together to address the same subject. These lines of text may be synonymous, antithetical, or progressive. But the important point to note is that both lines are intended to clarify the topic of discussion and the sage’s perspective on the subject.

For example, Prov 18:11a states, “The wealth of the rich man is his strong city.” If read on its own, this line would suggest that wealth serves as a source of security for those who are rich. However, the second line provides an important clarification when it says, “And [it is] like a high wall in his imagination.” By adding the parallel line, Solomon actually undermines the notion that riches offer real security to those who have them. But readers only arrive at this understanding if they read the first line in the light of the second.

Despite initial appearances, Prov 12:10 is not primarily about animals

Similarly, when we read Prov 12:10a in light of 12:10b, we quickly realize that this text is about much more than animals. If Solomon was primarily concerned with animal welfare, we would expect him to bring up the issue once more in 12:10b. However, Solomon’s focus shifts away from animals and towards the (so-called) compassion of the wicked, which he describes as cruelty. Given how often Solomon compares and contrasts the righteous and the wicked, it becomes readily apparent what the proverb is really about: the difference between the righteous and the wicked in relation to their compassion.

On the one hand, the verse states that a righteous person is one who is so filled with compassion that his care extends even beyond the bounds of human society. Not only does he care for those within his household, but he even concerns himself with the state of his cattle.

Here, I would argue that the reference to the righteous caring for “his beasts” is intended to serve a primarily rhetorical function: it highlights (in contrast to the wicked) the depths of the righteous person’s compassion. While it does have a bearing on how people should treat animals, the verse is really a call for readers to examine whether or not their lives are marked by generous compassion because such generous compassion is inseparable from true righteousness.

On the other hand, Solomon contends that the wicked are so filled with malice that what they consider to be compassionate leads only to more suffering. The proverb uses the adjective “cruel” (אכזרי) to describe the compassion of the wicked. This same adjective is used in prophetic literature to refer to the destructive ferocity of armies used by YHWH to level nations in His judgment (Isa 13:9; Jer 6:23; 30:14; 50:42). The word is used to speak of realities that bring about immense levels of pain and destruction; and according to Solomon, the so-called “compassion” of the wicked should be classed as one of these destructive realities.

Perhaps if Christians today reflected on the intended meaning of Prov 12:10, we would find it to be helpful on two fronts. First, the verse would help us by convicting us of our lack of compassion. While we have been made righteous through faith in Christ, Christians are called to live lives filled with righteousness after the model of Christ himself. But according to Prov 12:10, true righteousness evidences itself in generous compassion. How generous is our compassion? Do we feel and express compassion for all kinds of people? Or is our compassion constrained somehow? Do we refuse to care for the plight of those who look different than us, think differently than us, vote differently than us, worship differently than us, or otherwise live differently than us?

When we remember Prov 12:10, we are given insight into why a society that prizes compassion simultaneously champions so many causes that lead only to more suffering and destruction.

But in addition, the verse would also help us to learn how to live within our current culture. When we remember Prov 12:10, we are given insight into why a society that prizes compassion simultaneously champions so many causes that lead only to more suffering and destruction. This proverb helps us understand how, under the guise of euphemisms and misnomers such as “gender-affirming care,” “women’s choice,” “reproductive rights,” “aid-in-dying,” and a host of others, our culture can continue to pursue courses of action deemed “compassionate” that in reality promote harm and death. Finally, the verse can provide us with confidence to stand firm when we are accused of lacking compassion for our refusal to support such allegedly “compassionate” causes. Proverbs 12:10 reminds us that, when we refuse to go along with the culture on these fronts, it is not because we lack compassion. On the contrary, it is because we, by the grace of God, are able to recognize the difference between compassion and cruelty.

Richard M. Blaylock, PhD

Richard is assistant professor of biblical studies at Western Seminary. Read his bio.

On Compassion and Cruelty: A Brief Reflection on Proverbs 12:10 — Transform (2024)
Top Articles
Binance may have reduced its Bitcoin withdrawal limit, but other crypto exchanges are even more stringent
U.S. TikTok influencers by number of followers 2021 | Statista
Devotion Showtimes Near Xscape Theatres Blankenbaker 16
Calvert Er Wait Time
Cappacuolo Pronunciation
Craigslist Houses For Rent In Denver Colorado
Robot or human?
Koordinaten w43/b14 mit Umrechner in alle Koordinatensysteme
Hawkeye 2021 123Movies
Trade Chart Dave Richard
Tlc Africa Deaths 2021
Find The Eagle Hunter High To The East
6th gen chevy camaro forumCamaro ZL1 Z28 SS LT Camaro forums, news, blog, reviews, wallpapers, pricing – Camaro5.com
Job Shop Hearthside Schedule
Beau John Maloney Houston Tx
Radio Aleluya Dialogo Pastoral
Craigslist List Albuquerque: Your Ultimate Guide to Buying, Selling, and Finding Everything - First Republic Craigslist
Sky X App » downloaden & Vorteile entdecken | Sky X
Bend Pets Craigslist
2016 Hyundai Sonata Refrigerant Capacity
使用 RHEL 8 时的注意事项 | Red Hat Product Documentation
라이키 유출
Palm Springs Ca Craigslist
Ups Print Store Near Me
What Time Does Walmart Auto Center Open
Bj타리
FAQ's - KidCheck
Ou Football Brainiacs
When His Eyes Opened Chapter 3123
Funky Town Gore Cartel Video
Rocketpult Infinite Fuel
Blue Beetle Movie Tickets and Showtimes Near Me | Regal
Covalen hiring Ai Annotator - Dutch , Finnish, Japanese , Polish , Swedish in Dublin, County Dublin, Ireland | LinkedIn
Movies123.Pick
Missouri State Highway Patrol Will Utilize Acadis to Improve Curriculum and Testing Management
Google Jobs Denver
Delaware judge sets Twitter, Elon Musk trial for October
Wisconsin Women's Volleyball Team Leaked Pictures
Trivago Myrtle Beach Hotels
Lovely Nails Prices (2024) – Salon Rates
Three V Plymouth
Acts 16 Nkjv
Arigreyfr
Divinity: Original Sin II - How to Use the Conjurer Class
Grizzly Expiration Date Chart 2023
How To Customise Mii QR Codes in Tomodachi Life?
9:00 A.m. Cdt
Backpage New York | massage in New York, New York
Evil Dead Rise - Everything You Need To Know
Buildapc Deals
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Prof. An Powlowski

Last Updated:

Views: 5746

Rating: 4.3 / 5 (64 voted)

Reviews: 87% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Prof. An Powlowski

Birthday: 1992-09-29

Address: Apt. 994 8891 Orval Hill, Brittnyburgh, AZ 41023-0398

Phone: +26417467956738

Job: District Marketing Strategist

Hobby: Embroidery, Bodybuilding, Motor sports, Amateur radio, Wood carving, Whittling, Air sports

Introduction: My name is Prof. An Powlowski, I am a charming, helpful, attractive, good, graceful, thoughtful, vast person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.