Automated online investment advisors, or robo-advisors, have gained popularity in recent years. This technology has upended the financial planning and wealth management industries. If you're comfortable with automated investing and don't have sophisticated needs, you might be interested in choosing one.
But how do you evaluate the options and determine the best robo-advisor to use? Here are some tips that can help you decide.
Key Takeaways
- First, take a look at the services provided. Many robo-advisors now have standard tax-loss harvesting and automatic rebalancing at no additional cost.
- Second, compare the expenses you'll incur at each robo-advisor.
- Finally, evaluate the costs and fees charged by the robo-advisors you are interested in and weigh those against traditional advisors.
Identify Robo-Advisor Services
The first step is to determine what type(s) of financial advice and services you need. Most robo-advisors manage your portfolio; some firms have added the benefits of budgeting and financial planning and may also provide access to an expert for assistance.
Basic Services
For the most part, portfolio management and asset allocation are the staple services that robo-advisors provide. They do it via the use of an algorithm that is based on Modern Portfolio Theory, generally using exchange-traded funds (ETFs).
Some firms such as Folio Investing and M1 Finance offer pre-built portfolios of stocks or ETFs that clients can buy with a click. Others walk clients through a goal-setting process and recommend a portfolio that fits their timeline and risk preferences.
Addtional Services
Above this basic level of service, some of the best robo-advisors offer tax-loss harvesting services for portfolios that are not tax-advantaged in some way, such as an IRA. Many now include tax optimization strategies, but keep in mind that tax-loss harvesting is not always beneficial—it all depends on your tax situation.
Some robo-advisors that offer tax-loss harvesting will only do so if you opt-in, so be sure to read the documentation carefully.
You may find robo-advisors with specialties. For example, Vanguard Digital Advisor specializes in low-cost index fund portfolios and Personal Capital, offers the ability to manage all of your accounts on a consolidated basis, and is aimed at a slightly more upscale market.
You can find robo-advisors joining in on emerging and growing tech as well. For instance, Betterment, one of the first robo-advisors, now offers cryptocurrency portfolios to clients.
Compare Robo-Advisor Expenses
Each broker will have a fee schedule for their digital advisors. Fees generally range from 0.15% to 0.50% of the assets under management. In addition, some advisors charge a one-time setup fee.
Personal Capital's fees range from 0.49% to 0.89% of the amount invested. Acorns charges $3 every month, while Betterment and Wealthfront, have a low monthly fee or a simple 0.25% annual fee based on the dollar amount of assets you have under management.
Don't forget the expense ratios and transaction costs of the underlying exchange-traded funds or mutual funds. Unless the broker has other agreements or arrangements, they will still apply.
Compare Robo-Advisors and Traditional Services
Robo-advisors began with the idea that minimal human involvement could lower costs with the ability to set-it-and-forget-it, letting the algorithms run the show. However, there may be times when you'd want to talk to a professional.
Betterment was the first robo-advisor to bring in actual financial advisors to help field questions and give investors peace of mind. Several other robo-advisors have followed suit; many assign users a personalized advisor.
If you choose to involve a human advisor, it's essential to remember that they need to be paid. The brokerages with robo-advisors which employ human advisors may charge higher investment management fees or a one-time fee for a consultation.
Human financial advisors are there to answer questions, field general financial advice, help present options, or reassure you if the markets are getting you down.
Popular Robo-Advisors
Robo-advisor popularity has not been lost on major players in the financial services industry. Established firms in the self-directed trading industry have launched robo-advisors to appeal to clients who want to set aside some of their assets to be managed passively. These robo-advisors are part of a more extensive offering that includes banking and self-directed brokerage services:
- Wealthfront
- Betterment
- M1 Finance
- Merrill Guided Investing
- E*TRADE Core Portfolios
- Ally Managed Portfolios
- Charles Schwab Intelligent Portfolios
- Fidelity GO
- Interactive Advisors
- TD Ameritrade Essential Portfolios
- Vanguard Digital Advisor
- JP Morgan Automated Investing
- Wells Fargo Intuitive Investor
These companies have the money to invest and the time to allow these services to grow.Additionally, if your needs change or you decide you'd like a more personal touch, you can transition to other services these firms offer.
Can You Trust a Robo-Advisor to Manage Your Investments?
Robo-advisors are generally safe to use. They have more than fifteen years of history behind them, so you can expect a robo-advisor to be able to invest on your behalf. Of course, investing is still subject to risk, so you need to keep an eye on your investment's performance and consider each robo-advisor's strategy and specialty before investing.
Also consider that your investments are covered by the Securities Investor Protection Corporation (SIPC). This won't protect you from your investments losing value, but will ensure that your investments are protected, up to $500,000, if the robo-advisor goes bankrupt or loses track of your assets.
How Important Are Robo-Advisor Fees?
Fees can play a big role in long-term returns. Imagine you invested $10,000 for 20 years, earning an average return of 10% annually before fees. If you pay a 0.10% management fee, that reduces your effective annual return to 9.9%. After 20 years, you'd have $66,062.32.
If the fee were 0.50%, your effective annual return would drop to 9.5%. After 20 years, your investment would grow to $61,416.12. That's an ending balance $4,646.20 lower than the investment that charged just 0.10%. A seemingly small difference of 0.40% would cost you nearly $5,000 over the course of twenty years.
How Much Can You Save By Tax-Loss Harvesting?
Tax-loss harvesting can help investors reduce the taxes they pay on investment gains, thereby improving their returns. In volatile markets, the savings can be significant. A study from Vanguard indicated that tax-loss harvesting can improve returns by as much as 0.95% while Wealthfront claims an increase in after-tax returns of 1.85% .
How Do Robo-Advisors Design Your Portfolio?
When you sign up for a robo-advisor, you typically answer questions about your income, debt, financial situation, age, risk-tolerance and goals. The robo-advisor uses your responses to build a portfolio that aligns with your goals and risk-tolerance.
The Bottom Line
With robo-advisors more popular than ever, it's even more important to understand how to compare different services and choose the right one for you. Look beyond each service's basic offerings and consider additional services that you could use in the future. Also think about the impact that fees could have on your long-term returns before settling on a robo-advisor.
