How Swiss authorities bungled Credit Suisse oversight (2024)

About six months before Credit Suisse was sold to rival UBS in a weekend rescue, the head of the Swiss central bank wanted to inject 50 billion Swiss francs ($57.6 billion) into the lender and nationalise it, according to three sources with direct knowledge of the matter.

Hobbled by a series of scandals and failed restructuring plans under successive management teams, Credit Suisse had experienced massive deposit outflows in October 2022. Swiss National Bank Chairman Thomas Jordan and other officials believed the lender faced an existential crisis that could not be solved by just injecting cash, two of the sources said.

Nationalising the bank would have allowed regulators to install new managers who could restore confidence, one person with knowledge of the matter said.

But Switzerland's financial regulator FINMA and the finance ministry opposed the idea, as did Credit Suisse's management, the sources said. Unable to agree, Swiss authorities decided the best solution was to let the company find its own way, the three sources added.

The episode, many details of which are reported here for the first time, was one of several points of friction among Swiss officials in recent years over how to regulate the country's banks, including how much deference to give management teams.

Interviews with more than two dozen people, including current and former officials, industry executives and advisers, show those differences undermined the ability of Swiss regulators to properly oversee Credit Suisse, which became the first systemically important bank to collapse since the financial crisis of 2008.

Amid the lax oversight, Credit Suisse hurtled from one scandal to the next. Taken together, that meant when the lender in effect became insolvent in March due to a run on deposits, Swiss authorities were unprepared and had only one realistic option: to sell it to rival UBS, supported by more than 200 billion francs in state-funded guarantees, the interviews show.

Credit Suisse's demise tainted Switzerland's reputation as a major center of world finance and a safe haven, and debunked the belief that global banks are safer now.

Better understanding of what happened can help strengthen global financial regulation and hold Swiss regulators accountable now that they oversee an even bigger bank: after acquiring Credit Suisse, UBS has a balance sheet of more than $1.6 trillion, nearly twice the size of the Swiss economy.

"Many people here feel that it would've been much better if policymakers had acted much earlier," said Stefan Gerlach, chief economist of Switzerland's EFG Bank and former deputy governor of Ireland's central bank. "One element common to many financial crashes is that politicians are often too quick to accept the views of the largest banks."

A finance ministry spokesperson said the government had examined temporary public ownership of Credit Suisse but it was not "the best available solution." He said that the government was now reviewing bank regulation.

The spokesperson did not say when they considered nationalisation nor elaborate further.

A FINMA spokesperson said the regulator started demanding concrete steps from Credit Suisse as early as the summer of 2022 to prepare for a crisis, showing it recognised the risk of a "destabilisation of the bank." The steps included asking Credit Suisse to prepare for the sale of business units, and later, the sale of the entire bank.

FINMA had alternatives to a sale to UBS, such as a resolution or nationalisation of the bank, the spokesperson added. The regulator will release a report on Tuesday outlining its handling of the crisis at the bank.

Spokespeople for the SNB and UBS declined to comment.

The hastily arranged sale to UBS allowed regulators to avoid a messy collapse and wider impact on global financial stability.

Daniel Zuberbuehler, Switzerland's chief regulator when UBS was bailed out in 2008, said: "It's difficult to decide when is the right moment to intervene."

"Had Credit Suisse collapsed, it would have been a nuclear bomb on the economy," Zuberbuehler said. "Nonetheless, it is no success story that we have lost one of our two big banks."

EARLY WORRIES

SNB's Jordan started worrying about Credit Suisse as early as February 2020, when Tidjane Thiam left as chief executive after it came to light that the bank had spied on some of its top executives, one of the sources with direct knowledge of the matter said.

There was little public display of regulators' concern, however, as they phrased any warnings about the bank "very carefully" to avoid creating panic, the source said.

Meanwhile, the situation at the bank kept worsening.

In 2020, as the COVID-19 pandemic caused a rush for cash, Credit Suisse struggled to meet its funding needs, according to four people with direct knowledge of the matter.

The crunch, which has not been previously reported, happened as counterparties demanded more collateral for funds, something Credit Suisse had trouble providing. The bank was struggling to cope with large clients drawing down credit lines, two of the sources said.

In its annual report at the time, Credit Suisse said it had seen an increase in net cash outflows in 2020, which weakened its liquidity buffers but the bank maintained it had "strong liquidity and funding." The details of what happened were not publicly known.

The events led FINMA to force Credit Suisse to hold higher liquidity buffers, three of the sources said. The move would allow the bank to buy more time from regulators in October 2022. Reuters could not determine by how much the buffers were increased.

Credit Suisse's cash cushions also came under pressure as it was hit by successive scandals, which showed poor risk management practices at the bank. In early 2021, the Swiss lender was hit with losses from dealings with a lender called Greensill amid fraud allegations. Just a few weeks later, it lost billions of dollars when hedge fund Archegos collapsed.

Both episodes led to outflows from the bank, causing Swiss regulators to heighten supervision, with steps such as asking for daily liquidity reports that show how much cash it could easily access, according to a source with direct knowledge of the matter.

LACK OF POWER

FINMA's powers as a financial regulator are among the weakest in the Western world, lacking some basic tools such as the ability to fine banks, something the agency unsuccessfully lobbied the government from 2021 to change.

That year FINMA went to the Swiss finance ministry, making the case for additional powers as well as the creation of a financial liquidity backstop like the United States and some other jurisdictions have, according to a former Swiss official. A liquidity backstop is a financing facility that banks can tap in an emergency, allowing the central bank to act as the lender of last resort.

In FINMA's view the liquidity backstop was crucial as well as a final building block needed for any resolution plan to work, the former official said. In the aftermath of the 2008 financial crisis, global banks such as Credit Suisse were required to create resolution plans, called living wills, which would allow regulators to unwind them without creating broader systemic issues.

At the time, FINMA did not get support from the ministry, the former official said. The finance minister then was Ueli Maurer, a member of the pro-bank Swiss People's Party.

Under Maurer, the finance ministry had gravitated towards the banks, which were complaining that FINMA was too intrusive, according to three people with direct knowledge of the work of the regulator and banks' views.

Banks lobbied the government to restrain FINMA's then-chief executive, Mark Branson, a former banker viewed by the industry as too tough, these people said.

Maurer, who retired in late 2022, did not respond to a request for comment.

In a December 2022 interview with Swiss television, Maurer expressed confidence in Credit Suisse's ability to turn the corner. "You just have to leave them alone for a year or two," he said.

In early 2021, Marlene Amstad, a former academic, took over as chair of FINMA. Soon after she started, she began requesting information from FINMA officials about supervision of banks, a move that insiders took as a way for her to look over Branson's shoulder, one former official said.

Then, she asked to attach additional staff to the supervisory board of FINMA, which would have allowed her to further increase scrutiny of Branson's team. This executive staff function was eventually not established after FINMA officials resisted, the former official said.

A few months later, Branson left to go to German regulator Bafin. His departure heralded a shake up that saw the departure of key supervisors responsible for banks and the winding up of troubled lenders.

The FINMA spokesperson said Amstad did not interfere in supervisory work but rearranged the supervisory board's activity to focus on fewer topics, deepening their understanding of those. The board itself had decided not to pursue the idea of additional staff and the agency's staffing had not fluctuated much for years, the spokesperson said.

BANK RUN

For regulators, the red lights started flashing in October last year, when a social media post from a journalist that a 'major international investment bank is on the brink' led to a run on Credit Suisse, two of the sources said.

During the weeks that followed, customers pulled out more than 100 billion francs.

FINMA set up a crisis group, one of the sources said. The regulator also instructed Credit Suisse to prepare contingency plans, including data rooms for a sale of some or all of the business, one source said.

The FINMA spokesperson confirmed the regulator had asked the bank to prepare for a sale.

But FINMA was not in favor of Jordan's suggestion of nationalizing the bank. One of the sources said FINMA felt replacing the top layer of management would not be effective as its problems went much deeper.

It would be easier for UBS, which could shake up management ranks better than the government could, the source said.

There were also limits to what FINMA could make the bank do. Thanks in part to the buffers put in place during the pandemic, the cash numbers that Credit Suisse reported were within most regulatory requirements, undermining regulators' ability to force the bank's hand, three of the sources said.

Still, Credit Suisse said in October 2022 that clients had pulled funds at a pace that saw the lender breach some regulatory requirements for liquidity. Reuters could not learn additional details about the breaches.

Credit Suisse management sought to soldier on without support, a bank executive said. Fearing that news of an emergency funding would leak and trigger disaster, executives warned regulators of the bad 'signal' such a move would send, according to one of the sources, who is a former Swiss official.

Despite preparing various press releases to announce a possible central bank facility, illustrating how close it came, the bank ultimately refused, three of the sources said.

Credit Suisse went on to raise $4.2 billion from investors by selling shares later that year. Then withdrawals started to ease, defusing the immediate pressure.

But the calm was brief.

As a regional U.S. banking crisis spread to Europe in March, depositors worried about the safety of their money started withdrawing billions from Credit Suisse once again.

Credit Suisse sought to shore up its finances. Now, it wanted regulators' help. It calculated that a lifeline of 50 billion francs from the SNB would be enough, according to a Credit Suisse executive with direct knowledge of the matter.

In a scramble for foreign currencies, the SNB turned to the U.S. Federal Reserve, using a little-known line of funding to withdraw about $60 billion, the maximum allowed, without publicity, two sources with knowledge of the matter said.

The Fed declined to comment.

As the SNB dashed to plug funding holes in a desperate bid to keep Credit Suisse afloat, the head of a little-known group of politicians in charge of emergency taxpayer funds, Ursula Schneider Schuttel, received a phone call.

Credit Suisse needed cash - fast.
The new Swiss finance minister, Karin Keller-Sutter, told Schneider Schuttel in a call on the evening of March 16, a Thursday, that they would have to sign off as much money as needed to save Credit Suisse. The country's financial and economic stability depended on it, she told the Social Democratic politician, according to a source familiar with the matter.

Schneider Schuttel had not been asked for help a few months prior, in October, but now they had to be ready by that weekend.

"It was a blank cheque," the source said. "We were told to get ready to approve the funds, but we didn't know how much."

That Sunday, UBS agreed to buy Credit Suisse for 3 billion francs in stock, with assistance from the Swiss government.

"After we rescued UBS, the promise was never would this happen again," Zuberbuehler said. "It has happened again."

(You can now subscribe to our Economic Times WhatsApp channel)

How Swiss authorities bungled Credit Suisse oversight (2024)

FAQs

Which Swiss financial regulator calls for stronger powers after Credit Suisse collapse? ›

The regulator therefore called for "extended options that would enable it to have more influence on the governance of supervised institutions." These include the implementation of a Senior Managers Regime, powers to impose fines and option of regularly publishing enforcement proceedings.

Who regulates Credit Suisse? ›

Credit Suisse Securities Europe Limited ("CSSEL") is authorised by the Prudential Regulation Authority and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority and the Prudential Regulation Authority in the United Kingdom.

Did Switzerland bail out Credit Suisse? ›

On March 19, 2023, the Swiss Federal Council (FC), the Swiss National Bank (SNB) and the Swiss Financial Market Supervisory Authority (FINMA), to whom we will refer collectively as the Swiss trinity, 1 undertook a joint rescue of Credit Suisse (CS) by orchestrating a merger with its domestic rival UBS Group AG (UBS).

What are the criticism of Credit Suisse? ›

The preparations made by Credit Suisse were not sufficient to exploit the full potential for liquidity assistance,” it said in the report. “First, in the case of certain assets, the requirements for a valid and enforceable delivery of collateral were not met.

Why did Finma fail to prevent Credit Suisse collapse? ›

It also examines FINMA's supervisory work with the bank. The key statements are as follows: Owing to the inadequate implementation of its strategic focus areas, repeated scandals and management errors, Credit Suisse lost the confidence of its clients, investors and the markets.

Who rescued Credit Suisse? ›

The Swiss government-sponsored rescue of Credit Suisse and U.S. bank salvages in March 2023 doused the immediate fires kindled by a run at little-known U.S. regional lender Silicon Valley Bank.

Who is responsible for Credit Suisse failure? ›

For some, Credit Suisse's management and ex-chairman Axel Lehmann are solely to blame for the collapse. For others, Switzerland's Financial Market Supervisory Authority (FINMA), led by Marlene Amstad, failed in its oversight task.

Who audits Credit Suisse? ›

PricewaterhouseCoopers (PwC), which has been Credit Suisse's auditor since 2020, will audit the acquired bank's accounts for 2023, according to the newspaper.

Who is suing Credit Suisse? ›

On June 6, U.S. law firm Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan filed suit on behalf of Credit Suisse bondholders in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York, claiming that the Swiss regulators' action was unlawful and an infringement of the bondholders' property rights.

What caused the demise of Credit Suisse? ›

Shakeups of Credit Suisse's board, particularly in the aftermath of the Greensill and Archegos scandals, led to a loss of institutional knowledge at the lender. This left Credit Suisse's board unable to find long-term solutions to its shortcomings, leading to a “poor risk culture” inside the institution.

Are Credit Suisse bonds now worthless? ›

Credit Suisse's $17B of risky bonds now worthless after takeover by UBS: 'Those bonds were created for moments like this' | Fortune.

Was UBS forced to take over Credit Suisse? ›

The Swiss government has forced through the takeover of stricken bank Credit Suisse by rival UBS for almost $3.25bn (£2.65bn) – well below its market value – amid fears that a failure to protect depositors would trigger a new global banking crisis.

Is Credit Suisse going out of business? ›

UBS Group AG completed the historic acquisition of its former rival Credit Suisse, marking a new chapter for the Swiss financial sector as the defunct bank's legal existence has formally ended.

How safe is Credit Suisse? ›

Credit Suisse uses state-​of-the-art systems to ensure your security during an online banking session. These include: Secure login through our SecureSign solution. Strong encryption of data.

What are the legal issues with Credit Suisse? ›

Many lawsuits have been filed in the United States and Switzerland over Credit Suisse's demise. These included claims on behalf of holders of about 16 billion Swiss francs ($18.2 billion) of bonds that Swiss regulators unexpectedly wrote down to zero.

Who is the regulator of Swiss banks? ›

The Swiss Financial Market Authority (FINMA) is the main regulatory and supervisory authority in Switzerland.

What are the powers of the Finma? ›

FINMA's statutory powers to supervise banks, insurers, stock exchanges, financial institutions and collective investment schemes are governed by a variety of financial market laws, including the Financial Market Supervision Act.

Who will take over Credit Suisse? ›

UBS confirmed its intention to take over Credit Suisse back in March 2023 with the deal subsequently reported to be worth more than $3.25 billion. The merger of UBS AG and Credit Suisse AG has officially completed – within the expected timeline.

Do Credit Suisse cds reach crisis levels as banks rush to buy protection? ›

Credit Suisse CDS Reach Crisis Levels as Banks Rush to Buy Protection. Banks that trade with Credit Suisse Group AG rushed to safeguard their exposure with the lender on Wednesday, snapping up contracts that will compensate them if the crisis rocking the Swiss lender deepens.

Top Articles
AGES Model: The Effective Elements For Long-Term Learning
Gen Z use lots of strange emojis. Here's what they are really trying to say
Chs.mywork
Lakers Game Summary
Here are all the MTV VMA winners, even the awards they announced during the ads
Craigslist Pet Phoenix
BULLETIN OF ANIMAL HEALTH AND PRODUCTION IN AFRICA
سریال رویای شیرین جوانی قسمت 338
Trade Chart Dave Richard
Clafi Arab
My Vidant Chart
2135 Royalton Road Columbia Station Oh 44028
How Many Cc's Is A 96 Cubic Inch Engine
Gma Deals And Steals Today 2022
What is Rumba and How to Dance the Rumba Basic — Duet Dance Studio Chicago | Ballroom Dance in Chicago
Po Box 35691 Canton Oh
Airrack hiring Associate Producer in Los Angeles, CA | LinkedIn
Wsop Hunters Club
Samantha Aufderheide
Orange Pill 44 291
St Clair County Mi Mugshots
Bòlèt Florida Midi 30
Drift Hunters - Play Unblocked Game Online
Il Speedtest Rcn Net
What Sells at Flea Markets: 20 Profitable Items
Riverstock Apartments Photos
Schooology Fcps
Amazing Lash Bay Colony
Proto Ultima Exoplating
Napa Autocare Locator
Baldur's Gate 3 Dislocated Shoulder
Ourhotwifes
Song That Goes Yeah Yeah Yeah Yeah Sounds Like Mgmt
Helloid Worthington Login
One Main Branch Locator
Daily Times-Advocate from Escondido, California
Keir Starmer looks to Italy on how to stop migrant boats
Japanese Big Natural Boobs
Mid America Irish Dance Voy
Sarahbustani Boobs
Celsius Claims Agent
Uc Davis Tech Management Minor
Professors Helpers Abbreviation
Rescare Training Online
Craigslist Chautauqua Ny
Euro area international trade in goods surplus €21.2 bn
Ciara Rose Scalia-Hirschman
Festival Gas Rewards Log In
Mike De Beer Twitter
Renfield Showtimes Near Regal The Loop & Rpx
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Dr. Pierre Goyette

Last Updated:

Views: 6577

Rating: 5 / 5 (50 voted)

Reviews: 89% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Dr. Pierre Goyette

Birthday: 1998-01-29

Address: Apt. 611 3357 Yong Plain, West Audra, IL 70053

Phone: +5819954278378

Job: Construction Director

Hobby: Embroidery, Creative writing, Shopping, Driving, Stand-up comedy, Coffee roasting, Scrapbooking

Introduction: My name is Dr. Pierre Goyette, I am a enchanting, powerful, jolly, rich, graceful, colorful, zany person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.