I once met a young man who insisted marriage ought to be a 50/50 relationship. He dug into his position, and would not consider my counter-arguments. Each spouse must contribute half, he said, or the deal is off. He was convinced that any other arrangement would not be fair.
Welcome to real marriage, it is not fair. It's a much better arrangement than simply being fair.
We at Family Fire do not believe the 50/50 model is compatible with a Christian view of marriage. Do you give up on a spouse who is ill and can't contribute their share? Would anyone really want a marriage where you throw out your covenant promises when one party is unable to carry their weight for a time? What if it's you?And, a 50/50 split of what, exactly? A 50/50 relationship contract as a model for marriage doesn't work well, and here are some reasons why.
It distorts the focus
Marriage should be characterized by interdependence on one another. When we draw a line and say, “I will give only this much and no more,” or “I will give only if Iget the same back from you, and I'll be measuring,” we miss out on the intimacy potential in marriage. Sometimes your spouse needs you. Sometimes you need your spouse. A 50/50 split is more like being roommates, not life mates. The focus of marriage is clinging together, forsaking all others, and offering grace and love to each other before God. We will hurt each other because we are each broken, and we are able to show Christ-like love to one another in ways not possible in other relationships. The focus is not on how I can get my share, but on how I can glorify God by loving another. The truth is, the vision is that both of you give self-sacrificially to the flourishing of one another. It's not "how little can I do?" but "how can we invest the best together?"
It can’t be measured
Even if we could divide physical efforts like chores, how would we measure emotional investment in the relationship? We might assign what we feel is the half our spouse must complete, but our spouse might do the same with differing ideas about where the line should be. Who will decide? Who wants to spend the length of our relationship bickering where to draw the line? We are selfish people by nature, and are tempted to look to see if our partner has done "their fair share," but marriage is notthat kind of partnership. It's better to ask how I can be encouraging my spouse to flourishin their God-given gifts.
It separates us
Marriage should display unity, but a 50/50 relationship is set up for failure before it begins. When we draw a 50/50 line down the center (whatever that is), we have already begun to focus on reasons forseparation rather than unification. The implication is that your spouse has to pull their 50 percent for this marriage to persist. So what happens when your partner perceives you as not pulling your weight? Real marriages will all experience times when one person—or both—feel like they are the only one contributing. What then? If your marriage is mostly about you and what you get out of it, you've already lost.
It is not biblical
Jesus called us to emulate his sacrificial love. He did not choose to love us only so far, but he loved us all the way to his death on the cross. I am glad that he did not quit! Jesus calls us to submit to one another out of our love for him. He did not call us to love to the halfway point, but to take on the form of a servant. Jesus said, "A new commandment I give to you, that you love one another: just as I have loved you, you also are to love one another" (John 13:34).To love as Jesus loved is a high calling and it is far more than a 50% love.
When we decide that our marriage relationship is worth 100 percent, we carry the burden of giving 100 percent of ourselves to it (and so does your spouse). When I am committed to giving 100 percent, there are no jobs outside of my responsibility. The focus is on what I am bringing to the relationship rather than on whether we are both doing our fair share. Don’t settle for a fair relationship; choose to give all of yourself and enjoy the blessings that follow.
