Are ESG Funds Worth It? A Guide for Sustainable Investors → ESG → Corporate Sustainability (2024)

Why ESG Investing Matters More Than Ever

ESG 'ESG' is a framework assessing environmental, social, and governance factors for organizational sustainability. investing's a form of sustainable investing that considers environmental, social, and governance criteria when selecting stocks, bonds, or funds. This type of investor seeks to invest in companies that are not only profitable, but also responsible and accountable for their impact on the planet and society.^[1]

ESG investing 'ESG Investing' considers environmental, social, and governance factors alongside financial metrics to invest in companies with sustainable practices and positive impact. isn't a niche or a fad but rather a growing trend that reflects the increasing awareness and demand for sustainability among investors, consumers, regulators, and society at large. According to a report by Morningstar, global assets in sustainable funds reached a record high of $2.3 trillion in 2021, up 29% from 2020.^[2] Moreover, a survey by Morgan Stanley found that 95% of individual investors are interested in sustainable investing, and 85% of asset owners are incorporating ESG factors into their investment decisions.^[3]

However, ESG funds are not all the same, though. They have different ESG goals, methods, and strategies, as well as different investment types, styles, and sectors. So let's take a closer look at how investors approach ESG investing and see how they pick and evaluate their investments.

What are ESG Funds and How Do They Work?

ESG funds are mutual funds or exchange-traded funds (ETFs) that invest in companies that meet certain environmental, social, and governance standards. ESG funds use various methods and strategies to select and evaluate their holdings, such as screening, integration, engagement, and impact.^[4]

Screening is the process of excluding or including companies based on their ESG performance or policies. Some may exclude companies that are involved in fossil fuels, tobacco, weapons, or gambling, or include companies that have positive ESG ratings or certifications.^[5]

Integration works by incorporating ESG factors into the financial analysis and valuation of companies. For example, they may consider how ESG issues affect the revenue, costs, risks, and opportunities of companies, and adjust their expected returns or weights accordingly.^[6]

Engagement is about interacting with companies to influence their ESG practices and disclosures. ESG funds may use their voting rights, dialogue, or shareholder resolutions to encourage companies to improve their ESG performance or transparency.^[7]

Finally, there's impact. This is the process of measuring and reporting the ESG outcomes and benefits of the investments. They may use indicators and metrics to quantify and communicate the environmental and social impact of their portfolio, such as carbon emissions, water usage, diversity, or human rights.^[8]

Unsurprisingly, ESG funds vary widely in their ESG criteria, methods, and strategies, as well as their investment objectives, styles, and sectors. Therefore, it's important for investors to understand the ESG approach and characteristics of each fund, and to compare them with their own preferences and expectations.

What are the Benefits and Challenges of ESG Funds?

ESG funds offer several benefits and challenges for investors, both in terms of financial performance and social impact:^[9]

• Financial Performance: ESG funds can potentially enhance the risk-adjusted returns of investors, by capturing the opportunities and avoiding the pitfalls of ESG issues. Such funds may benefit from the growing demand for sustainable products and services, the innovation and efficiency of ESG-oriented companies, and the lower regulatory and reputational risks of ESG-compliant companies. On the other hand, ESG funds may also come higher fees, lower diversification, and limited data and benchmarks.
• Social Impact: These funds do contribute to environmental and social sustainability by supporting the companies that are making a positive difference and influencing the ones that are lagging behind. For example, ESG funds do encourage businesses to reduce greenhouse gas emissions, conserve natural resources, protect human rights, and promote diversity and inclusion. On the flipside, there are often issues surrounding the measuring and reporting of their impact, ensuring consistency, and balancing their financial and social goals.

Therefore, ESG funds are not a panacea or a silver bullet for sustainable investing. They have their pros and cons, and they require careful research and analysis before investing. Investors should also be aware that ESG funds are not hom*ogeneous or standardized, and that they may have different definitions and interpretations of ESG criteria and performance.

How to Choose and Compare ESG Funds?

Given the diversity and complexity of ESG funds, how can investors choose and compare the ones that suit their needs and preferences? Typically, they approach through a number of different means:^[10]

• Defining Their ESG Goals and Priorities: Before looking for ESG funds, investors will first clarify their ESG goals and priorities. What are the ESG issues that they care about the most? What are the ESG standards that they expect from the companies that they invest in? What are the ESG outcomes that they want to achieve or support with their investments? They also consider financial goals and risk tolerance, and how they align with ESG goals and priorities.
• Research and Screen ESG Funds: Investors will undertake researching and screening ESG funds that match the goals and priorities set. They use various sources and tools to find and filter ESG funds, such as fund databases, ratings, reports, and websites. Successful investors pay attention to the ESG approach and characteristics of each fund, such as its ESG criteria, methods, strategies, performance, and impact. They also compare the ESG funds with their peers and benchmarks, and with their own preferences and expectations.
• Evaluate and Select ESG Funds: They then evaluate and select the ones that best fit their ESG goals and priorities. Again, they'll use various criteria and metrics to assess and rank ESG funds, such as their ESG ratings, scores, indicators, and metrics. As these funds must, like standard investments, deliver a return, ESG investors consider the fund's financial performance and risk, such as returns, volatility, fees, and diversification. They will also closely review their ESG policies and disclosures, such as their ESG objectives, targets, actions, and responsibilities.
• Monitor and Review ESG Funds: Finally, any investor, ESG investors included, closely monitor and review their ESG performance and impact on a regular basis. Various sources and tools are used to track and measure ESG funds, such as fund statements, reports, dashboards, and websites. They'll frequently update their ESG goals and priorities, and adjust their ESG portfolio accordingly, as ESG issues and opportunities evolve over time.

Following these steps can enable you to choose and compare ESG funds with more confidence and ease. You can also use the help of professional advisors or platforms that specialize in ESG investing, and that can provide you with more guidance and support.

What are the Future Trends and Opportunities of ESG Funds?

ESG investing is expected to grow and evolve in the coming years, as more investors, companies, regulators, and society at large embrace sustainability as a core value and a strategic imperative. Here are some of the future trends and opportunities of ESG funds:^[11]

• More demand and supply of ESG funds: ESG funds are likely to see more demand and supply in the future, as increasing numbers of investors seek to align their portfolios with their values and principles. More fund managers will respond to this demand by launching new ESG funds or enhancing existing ones. ESG funds are also likely to attract more capital from institutional investors, such as pension funds, sovereign wealth funds, and endowments, that have long-term horizons and fiduciary duties to consider ESG factors.^[12]
• More diversity and innovation: Such funds will increasingly cater to different investor preferences and needs, and as they leverage recent technologies and data sources. They'll offer more customization and personalization options, such as allowing investors to choose their own ESG criteria, weights, and thresholds. More advanced tools and methods, such as artificial intelligence, blockchain, and satellite imagery, to improve their ESG analysis and reporting, will certainly facilitate this.^[13]
• More regulation of ESG funds: ESG funds will face more regulation in the future, as regulators and industry bodies seek to ensure the quality, consistency, and transparency of ESG funds. So, we can expect to see such funds comply with more rules and guidelines, such as disclosing their ESG methodologies, metrics, and impacts, and adhering to common ESG frameworks and standards. ESG funds may also have to undergo more audits and assessments, such as by independent rating agencies, certification bodies, or verification providers.^[14]

These trends and opportunities indicate that ESG funds are here to stay and grow over time.

How to Start Your ESG Investing Journey

ESG investing requires a clear vision, a strong commitment, and proactive action, just like any investing approach.

To start your ESG investing journey, you can follow these steps:

• Assess Your Current Portfolio and ESG Profile: Before you invest in ESG funds, you should first assess your current portfolio and ESG profile. You can use various tools and services to analyze your portfolio and ESG profile, such as portfolio scanners, ESG calculators, or ESG advisors. There are even online quizzes or surveys to determine your ESG preferences and priorities.
• Set Your ESG Goals and Strategy: After you assess your current portfolio and ESG profile, set your ESG goals and strategy. Define your ESG objectives, targets, actions, and responsibilities, and align them with your financial goals and risk tolerance. You should also consider your ESG time horizon, and how you plan to monitor and review your ESG performance and impact.
• Choose and Invest in ESG Funds: Once you set your ESG goals and strategy, choose and invest in ESG funds that match them. Use the steps and tips that we discussed in the previous section to help you choose and compare ESG funds. Seek to diversify your ESG portfolio across different asset classes, sectors, regions, and themes, to optimize your risk-return trade-off and exposure to ESG opportunities.
• Engage and Collaborate with ESG Stakeholders and Initiatives: Finally, after you invest in ESG funds, you can engage with ESG stakeholders to enhance your ESG knowledge. Interact with other ESG investors, fund managers, companies, and experts, to exchange information, insights, and feedback. Participate in ESG initiatives and platforms, such as the UN 'Principles for Responsible Investment', the 'Global Reporting Initiative', or the 'World Benchmarking Alliance', to support the development and implementation of ESG policies, standards, and best practices.

Reading Guide

1. Investopedia | Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) Criteria ↑
2. Morningstar | Sustainable Fund Flows in 2020 Smash Previous Records ↑
3. Morgan Stanley | Sustainable Signals: Asset Owners Embrace Sustainability ↑
4. BlackRock | What is ESG investing? ↑
5. Fidelity | ESG screening ↑
6. Schroders | What is ESG integration? ↑
7. US SIF | The Impact of Sustainable and Responsible Investment ↑
8. Impact Management Project | Investor Portal ↑
9. CFA Institute | ESG Investing: A Review of the Practice ↑
10. Forbes | How To Choose ESG Funds ↑
11. PwC | The State of Climate Tech 2020 ↑
12. Bloomberg | ESG Assets May Hit $53 Trillion by 2025, a Third of Global AUM ↑
13. McKinsey & Company | How ESG could drive the next wave of innovation ↑
14. EY | How ESG regulation is shaping the future of sustainable investing ↑

FAQ