The case of an unidentified female found murdered in Brooks County in 1981 has been closed after the victim was finally identified as Shirlene Ann Hammack, also known as Cheryl.
The Murder
On Saturday, October 31, 1981, the body of an unidentified white female had been discovered beside a small, dirt lane entrance to a corn field, in the Dixie, Georgia community.
The victim had been partially covered by fresh cut limbs and foliage to conceal her and the crime. The victim was described as a woman about 5’2”,105 pounds, with shoulder length brown hair, and hazel eyes. She was believed to be between 18 to 24 years of age.
The cause of death was determined to be from a stab wound to her abdomen with associated strangulation. Following common practice without positive identification, she was given the name of “Jane Doe.”
The Suspect
Shortly after the murder, 52-year-old George Newsome was arrested. Investigators learned he was part of a traveling fair that was in the town of Quitman, Georgia during the time. Jane Doe was believed to also be employed with this traveling fair, but this was unknown. According to the GBI, at the time of his arrest, Newsome was in possession of a stolen motor home from another state.
A later search of the motor home resulted in the recovery of a rope that investigator’s said they believed had been used as a ligature to strangle Jane Doe. In addition to the strangulation, Jane Doe had been stabbed in the abdomen with a large knife. The knife was never recovered.
During the initial stages of the investigation, Newsome refused to cooperate with authorities and denied knowledge of the crime. Approximately one week after his arrest, he escaped from the Brooks County Jail and remained a fugitive until his capture on January 13, 1983, in Alabama.
After Newsome’s arrest as a fugitive, he admitted to the homicide of Jane Doe and said he had met her at the Fair Grounds in Tallahassee, Florida prior to coming to Quitman, Georgia. Newsome said that he had gotten into an argument with her about another man.
This argument eventually led to Jane Doe’s death. Newsome pled guilty and was sentenced to life in prison for her murder. Newsome died at the Augusta State Medical Prison on August 10, 1988 of natural causes. Prior to his death, either by purposeful omission or by his lack of knowledge, he never disclosed Jane Doe’s identity.
The Search for Answers
For years following the murder, the GBI and Brooks County Sheriff’s Office exhausted all available means at the time to identify the victim. Inquiries were sent across the State of Georgia and the United States regarding other missing females, who matched the description of Jane Doe in hopes of learning her identity.
Prior to her burial, she was displayed at a local funeral home in Brooks County, in an effort for individuals to stop by and attempt to identify her. Newspaper articles and other media outlets such as, “Unsolved Mysteries” were contacted in a continued attempt to identify her.
All the above efforts and countless hours of investigative work yielded negative results. Jane Doe was buried at Oak Hill Cemetery in Quitman, Georgia. The Bunting family from Brooks County graciously insisted that the girl not be buried in a pauper’s grave but be buried in their family plot in the cemetery.
Instead of being buried in a wooden coffin, in an un-vaulted grave that was not marked, she was buried in a quality casket, inside of a cement vault, with a marble slab over her resting place. A forensic sketch, which had been completed by the GBI during the investigation, was carved into the marble slab, along with the statement, “Known only to God.”
The case remained open as agents and investigators sought and hoped for a break in the case.
A Breakthrough
On Wednesday, October 31, 2018, 37 years to the date of the murder, the case agent was contacted by the Chief Deputy of the Brooks County Sheriff’s Office regarding a tip from a citizen who had walked into the Sheriff’s Office and alleged to have information on the identity of Jane Doe.
The citizen was a possible childhood friend of the murdered woman. This citizen believed Jane Doe to be Cheryl Hammack. The childhood friend recalled that she knew that her friend, Cheryl, had gone missing in the latter part of 1981 after traveling with the fair. The age and description of Cheryl had remarkable similarities to Jane Doe which peaked her interest. The friend had seen a Facebook post made by an area citizen close to Brooks County about the case. This post was shared many times and that is how the childhood friend saw it.
This chain of events led GBI Agents and Brooks County Investigators to speak with and soon meet in person with Cheryl’s surviving family members: her mother Kathleeen Hammack, her sister Johnnie Hay, and her sister Lynn Johnson. Cheryl’s family provided the full name of “Jane Doe” who is now identified as Shirlene “Cheryl” Ann Hammack. The description of Cheryl and the timeline of her going missing were consistent with the facts of this investigation.
Investigators then arranged a meeting with the family members to obtain a known DNA sample from her biological mother Kathleen. Agents and investigators also learned from the family that Cheryl’s mother had received a letter in the mail following her disappearance containing the contents of her wallet including her Georgia Driver’s License. The envelope and contents did not have a return address.
Exhumed
The Georgia Bureau of Investigation, Brooks County Sheriff’s Office, Brooks County Coroner, and Mr. Jim McGee of Stevens of McGee Funeral Services assisted in the exhumation of the remains per a court order that was obtained. The remains were exhumed and found to be in remarkable condition given the amount of time that had passed.
The quality condition of her remains could arguably be attributed to a caring Brooks County community at the time of her passing and a local family that paid to have her laid to rest in such a dignified manner in their family cemetery plot.
Once the casket containing remains were exhumed, it was then transported to the GBI Crime Lab in Macon by Coroner Joe Leverett and escorted by GBI Agents to obtain necessary DNA samples. After initial DNA tests were completed at the GBI Crime Lab in Moultrie, it was determined more advanced testing would be required and the samples were sent to the University of North Texas Center for Human Identification.
Following extensive analysis of the DNA samples and a comparison process, it was determined that Jane Doe was the biological child of Kathleen.
Jane Doe was finally identified as Cheryl Hammack. She was originally from Thomaston, Georgia and took a job with the Fair which eventually brought her to Brooks County in 1981.
Disclosure: This article may contain affiliate links, meaning we could earn a commission if you make a purchase through these links.
