Article
By Didier Cossin and Elisabeth Bourqui
5 min.
February 2020
PRINTABLE PDF – Less than 1MB
The governance of central banks is being challenged.
They have lost the clarity of their mandate, they are structurally losing their independence, and they are expected to fulfil social and quasi-political responsibilities without corresponding legitimacy and power.
These three key challenges to central bank governance may well trigger a monetary or currency regime shift that could transform economies and markets in the generation to come. All central banks, from the Federal Reserve and European Central Bank to the Bank of England, from Africa and Asia to Latin America and Oceania, face this triple challenge.
Let’s explore this evolution – or perhaps more accurately, this erosion – of the quality of governance in central banks in more detail.
Ambiguity of mandates
The aim of central banks used to be clear: to keep prices stable in order to hit a target of, for example, 2% inflation. Then this mandate began to change, and evolved towards dual mandates, like economic growth and job creation, often without precise targets.
So is the mandate stability or fostering a dynamic economy? Stability in a world where disruption has become a positive value has taken on an unexpected hue: it has become the stability of the graveyard.
The former governor of the Central Bank of Brazil talks about smoothing the cycle, hoping to reconcile dynamism and stability. But this became even more unclear during the financial crisis when the actions of central banks appeared to favour elites, such as bankers and shareholders and led to a rise in inequality.
There is a rising suspicion that mandates can no longer be purely technical, as the side-effects are all-encompassing. Social wellbeing, sustainability and environmental action and even industrial policies are indirectly influenced by central bank policies and the unelected officials who lead them.
Central banks are creating winners and losers in the socio-economic world, and this is making their mandates increasingly complex and ambiguous.
Erosion of independence
The independence of central banks used to be sacrosanct. It guaranteed a technocrat perspective with full responsibility and accountability around a well-defined, technical and non-political objective.
The rise of authoritarianism and the questioning of liberal democracies applied huge amounts of pressure on central bankers, with the politizisation of appointments and even removal from office a possibility.
Some of this politicization is justified due to the lack of clarity in central bank mandates, as discussed above. Indeed, the philosophy of markets and economics has moved away from the Chicago spirit of pure markets.
Some individual central bankers also seem to aspire to the political role and the grandstanding that comes with it. These forces fundamentally transform what good governance should be, by necessarily shifting power internally to boards rather than the individual. It also enhances system governance through new bodies such as financial stability committees, or gives more power to other institutional forces, such as the courts. An immediate consequence is also the loss of power of the typical central bank, ironically at the very time they are considered the most powerful economic actors in each country.
Rise of social and political responsibilities
The actions of central banks can no longer be considered socially or even politically neutral. Keeping interest rates low for a long time has given some central banks comfort, but it has also deeply affected the sustainability of the pension funds belonging to a large number of people, while favouring some yield-seeking private actors.
Emergency actions cannot be seen as neutral either, hence the sudden social responsibility of lenders of last resort. Social trust in central banks, and in central bankers, has thus been affected and expectations are for them to act responsibly in terms of maintaining the financial health of the population, consumer protections, climate change mitigation and to prevent social inequalities.
This expectation of social responsibility has emerged at a time when central banks are losing their economic clout. The Phillips Curve has flattened, the massive balance sheets of central banks are not used strategically, and low interest rates have revealed the asymmetry of their power with the limitation of the Zero Bound (and the risk of cash herding and inefficiency with negative rates).
Despite these challenges, central banks can play an important role in our social and economic future, notably in terms of our economic wellbeing and the sustainability of our ecosystems.
The best-in-class will act decisively, often in unfamiliar territory. The art of quality decision making is central to good governance. Hence the need for central bankers to address these governance challenges and to engage in a sincere and accountable conversation with the population – and their role in our future.
Contact
for additional information on IMD publications
Related topics
Finance
Corporate Governance
Sustainability
Browse all topics
Related topics
Finance
Corporate Governance
Sustainability
Browse all topics
Discover our latest research
IMD's faculty and research teams publish articles, case studies, books and reports on a wide range of topics
All articles
Keep reading
Article
Impact orientation and venture capital financing: The interplay of governmental, social impact and traditional venture capital
In addition to traditional venture capital (VC), governmental VC and social impact VC investors have emerged as alternatives to fund entrepreneuria...
Finance Venture Capital Social Innovation
By Valentina Lo Mele, Anita Quas, Patrick Reichert and Stefano Romito
in Finance Research Letters
October 2024, vol. 68, 105987, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.frl.2024.105987
Read more
Impact orientation and venture capital financing: The interplay of governmental, social impact and traditional venture capital
By Valentina Lo MeleAnita QuasPatrick ReichertandStefano Romito
inFinance Research LettersOctober 2024, vol. 68, 105987, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.frl.2024.105987
Summary
In addition to traditional venture capital (VC), governmental VC and social impact VC investors have emerged as alternatives to fund entrepreneuria...
Contact
for additional information on IMD publications
Related topics
Finance
Venture Capital
Social Innovation
Browse all topics
Creating value by cutting carbon - Skanska - Lena Hök
By Lena Hök
inI by IMD
Summary
Skanska’s Lena Hök describes how the construction company’s focus on cutting emissions helps it develop solutions for customers
Read more
Contact
for additional information on IMD publications
Related topics
Sustainability
Browse all topics
Can the BRICS+ help the world transition to climate neutrality?
By André Brotto
inI by IMD
Summary
SustainabilityCan the BRICS+ help the world transition to climate neutrality?by André Brotto Published 16 September 2024 in Sustainability • 6 min ...
Read more
Contact
for additional information on IMD publications
Related topics
Sustainability
Browse all topics
Embedding responsible innovation in corporate strategy
By Bala MullothJill KickulandTatiana Iakovleva
inI by IMD
Summary
Innovation is a core element in the business toolbox. A new framework is helping corporate leaders integrate social sustainability in their innovat...
Read more
Contact
for additional information on IMD publications
Related topics
Innovation
Sustainability
Browse all topics
Embedding responsible innovation in corporate strategy
By Bala MullothJill KickulandTatiana Iakovleva
inI by IMD9 September 2024
Summary
Innovation is a core element in the business toolbox. A new framework is helping corporate leaders integrate social sustainability in their innovat...
Read more
Contact
for additional information on IMD publications
Related topics
Innovation
Sustainability
Strategy
Browse all topics
Why mining matters in the era of climate change
By Carlos Cordon
inI by IMD3 September 2024
Summary
The mining sector's ability to produce the raw materials required for climate change mitigation will have significant supply chain implications, ar...
Read more
Contact
for additional information on IMD publications
Related topics
Supply Chain
Sustainability
Browse all topics
How to make money on sustainability
By Knut HaanaesBryony Jansen van TuyllandØystein D. Fjeldstad
inI by IMD
Summary
Unpacking how a company creates value is crucial to reap the rewards of sustainable transformation, say Knut Haanaes, Oystein Fjeldstad, and Bryony...
Read more
Contact
for additional information on IMD publications
Related topics
Sustainability
Browse all topics
Why a new nature of business is needed for sustainable prosperity
By Julia Binder
inI by IMD
Summary
How to reinvent business models and create sustainable prosperity by working with, rather than against, the interests of nature and society. Capita...
Read more
Contact
for additional information on IMD publications
Related topics
Sustainability
Browse all topics
Why a new nature of business is needed for sustainable prosperity
By Julia Binder
inI by IMD
Summary
How to reinvent business models and create sustainable prosperity by working with, rather than against, the interests of nature and society. Capita...
Read more
Contact
for additional information on IMD publications
Related topics
Sustainability
Browse all topics
How to make money on sustainability
By Knut Bjarne HaanaesBryony Jansen van TuyllandØystein D. Fjeldstad
inI by IMD2 September 2024
Summary
Unpacking how a company creates value is crucial to reap the rewards of sustainable transformation, say Knut Haanaes, Oystein Fjeldstad, and Bryony...
Read more
Contact
for additional information on IMD publications
Related topics
Sustainability
Value Creation
Browse all topics