23 Delicious and Impressive Recipes to Make for Your Next Cookie Swap (2024)

Table of Contents

Stained-Glass Sugar Cookies Chocolate-Peanut-Butter-Caramel Cereal Bars Tropical Fruit Biscotti Noel Nut Balls Bacon Potato-Chip Chocolate Cookie Meyer-Lemon Shortbread Wreath Cookies Hazelnut Tri-Color Cookies Iced Chocolate Waffle Cookies Lamington Thumbprint Cookies Martha's Tahini Cookies Cacao Cookies Snowmen Shortbread Cookies Gingerbread-Espresso Crinkle Cookies Crushed Peppermint Chocolate Cookies Lime Sandwich Cookies Fruitcake Cookies Gingersnap Palmiers Peppermint Spritz Cookies Pecan Linzer Cookies Brussels Cookies Coconut Chip Cookies Crisp Sugar Doily Cookies Chewy Chocolate Gingerbread Cookies

Hosting or attending a cookie exchange (or swap) party is a time-honored holiday tradition. You bake a few dozen of your favorite cookies and get to take home several different types of treats in return. Gathering friends and family together for one of these parties is also a great chance to catch up, build community, and get creative in the kitchen.

Whether you are a veteran of the cookie swap or a first timer, there are a range of recipes in this collection right for you. Those who are going to their very first cookie exchange should know the unwritten rule of these swaps: First and foremost, the cookies should not only taste good, but they need to have a polished presentation, too. Save the homely-looking cookies for Santa's plate and go for the gold with any of the recipes here.

01of 23

Stained-Glass Sugar Cookies

23 Delicious and Impressive Recipes to Make for Your Next Cookie Swap (1)

You'll dazzle your cookie swap recipients with these surprisingly easy sugar cookies which can be created in several stained-glass-inspired colorways.

View Recipe

02of 23

Chocolate-Peanut-Butter-Caramel Cereal Bars

23 Delicious and Impressive Recipes to Make for Your Next Cookie Swap (2)

Different and delicious, these bar cookies look like a million dollars but are easy to make—and no-bake to boot. The base is crispy rice cereal and marshmallow; then comes a layer of peanut-butter caramel and a chocolate-shell topping.

View Recipe

03of 23

Tropical Fruit Biscotti

23 Delicious and Impressive Recipes to Make for Your Next Cookie Swap (3)

A departure from traditional Italian biscotti, this twice-baked treat has bright pockets of papaya and candied ginger that flavor every crunchy bite.

View Recipe

04of 23

Noel Nut Balls

23 Delicious and Impressive Recipes to Make for Your Next Cookie Swap (4)

Whether you call them snowballs, Russian tea cakes, Mexican wedding cookies, or noel nut balls, no cookie collection would be complete without this melt-in-your-mouth confection.

View Recipe

05of 23

Bacon Potato-Chip Chocolate Cookie

23 Delicious and Impressive Recipes to Make for Your Next Cookie Swap (5)

With bacon and potato chips in the mix, these sweet-and-salty treats really need no further introduction and will be the talk of this year's cookie swap.

View Recipe

06of 23

Meyer-Lemon Shortbread Wreath Cookies

23 Delicious and Impressive Recipes to Make for Your Next Cookie Swap (6)

These wreath cookies look spectacular arranged on a platter. The best part? This on-theme Christmas cookie is made from buttery shortbread dough and is painted with a bright lemony glaze.

View Recipe

07of 23

Hazelnut Tri-Color Cookies

23 Delicious and Impressive Recipes to Make for Your Next Cookie Swap (7)

Do you love a good baking project? Look no further than these festive layer cookies inspired by the rainbow cookie. Containing three layers of raspberry, pistachio, and hazelnut cookies, there's no denying that they'll take most of an afternoon to make—but the payoff is worth it.

View Recipe

08of 23

Iced Chocolate Waffle Cookies

23 Delicious and Impressive Recipes to Make for Your Next Cookie Swap (8)

Is your waffle maker underused at the moment? Spread this cinnamon-spiked chocolate batter on the grates and wait for it to turn into crisp cookies with a design that will make people wonder how you pulled it off!

View Recipe

09of 23

Lamington Thumbprint Cookies

23 Delicious and Impressive Recipes to Make for Your Next Cookie Swap (9)

These modern thumbprint cookies have a chocolate-dipped bottom and a cheery jam center. Needless to say, they'll please a lot of different palates.

View Recipe

10of 23

Martha's Tahini Cookies

23 Delicious and Impressive Recipes to Make for Your Next Cookie Swap (10)

For a nut-free treat that offers seriously good flavor, try these sesame-laced tahini cookies. The seeds add extra crunch and a nice presentation, while the tahini paste in the dough works to infuse the cookies with its signature flavor.

View Recipe

11of 23

Cacao Cookies

23 Delicious and Impressive Recipes to Make for Your Next Cookie Swap (11)

If you are a fan of the subtle flavor of milk chocolate, you'll love these lightly spiced cacao cookies. They're decorated with a coconut milk glaze and toasted coconut.

View Recipe

12of 23

Snowmen Shortbread Cookies

23 Delicious and Impressive Recipes to Make for Your Next Cookie Swap (12)

Move aside, gingerbread people! These snowman shortbread cookies will steal the show with their pretty powder-white coating and tender, buttery crumbs.

View Recipe

13of 23

Gingerbread-Espresso Crinkle Cookies

23 Delicious and Impressive Recipes to Make for Your Next Cookie Swap (13)

Espresso powder and a mix of both fresh and dried ginger work together to expertly spice every bite of these deliciously caffeinated cookies.

View Recipe

14of 23

Crushed Peppermint Chocolate Cookies

23 Delicious and Impressive Recipes to Make for Your Next Cookie Swap (14)

It couldn't be easier to decorate these sweets. All you need is crushed up peppermint candies. The cookies have a rich, deep-chocolate flavor thanks to Dutch-process cocoa powder.

View Recipe

15of 23

Lime Sandwich Cookies

23 Delicious and Impressive Recipes to Make for Your Next Cookie Swap (15)

These unique treats deliver a burst of sunshine through the lime custard that is sandwiched between two tender sugar cookies.

View Recipe

16of 23

Fruitcake Cookies

23 Delicious and Impressive Recipes to Make for Your Next Cookie Swap (16)

Unlike most regular fruitcakes, these classy cookies won't be accidentally left in the cupboard. Studded with candied cherries and dried papaya, then dipped in a dark chocolate fondant and garnished with edible gold, they are unforgettable.

View Recipe

17of 23

Gingersnap Palmiers

23 Delicious and Impressive Recipes to Make for Your Next Cookie Swap (17)

Easy, but impressive, too, these snappy spiced cookies use store-bought puff pastry for the dough. To jazz up the plain puff, a homemade ginger syrup and spiced sugar are painted on before baking.

View Recipe

18of 23

Peppermint Spritz Cookies

23 Delicious and Impressive Recipes to Make for Your Next Cookie Swap (18)

Spritz cookies are a fun, easy, and festive way to get into the holiday spirit. With a peppermint-flavored dough and a wreath-shaped cookie press, these treats will look especially cute in a tin with other holiday-themed spritz.

View Recipe

19of 23

Pecan Linzer Cookies

23 Delicious and Impressive Recipes to Make for Your Next Cookie Swap (19)

They're like ruby red jewels—and these gems will definitely stand out on a crowded cookie table. The buttery pecan dough that is used to sandwich the jam in these cookies is as memorable as their decorations.

View Recipe

20of 23

Brussels Cookies

23 Delicious and Impressive Recipes to Make for Your Next Cookie Swap (20)

These cookies are a homemade (not to mention gourmet) dupe for Pepperidge Farm's Brussels cookies. The dough yields a crisp, buttery cookie studded with hazelnuts and oats, which are then sandwiched between melted bittersweet chocolate.

View Recipe

21of 23

Coconut Chip Cookies

23 Delicious and Impressive Recipes to Make for Your Next Cookie Swap (21)

This recipe yields a thin, crisp, and buttery cookie that will become an instant favorite in your repertoire. The whopping 4 cups of rich, coconut flakes melds wonderfully with the buttery brown sugar cookie dough.

View Recipe

22of 23

Crisp Sugar Doily Cookies

23 Delicious and Impressive Recipes to Make for Your Next Cookie Swap (22)

If you are an experienced baker who loves to make intricate cookies, this is the recipe for you. It's a fun project that calls for punching intricate shapes out of the dough with aspic cutters.

View Recipe

23of 23

Chewy Chocolate Gingerbread Cookies

23 Delicious and Impressive Recipes to Make for Your Next Cookie Swap (23)

Is it the combination of fresh and ground ginger or the chunks of semisweet chocolate that make this cookie a favorite of our food editors? Maybe it's both—and the subtle flavor of molasses, all spice, cinnamon, and cloves in this egg-free, irresistible treat.

View Recipe